Have you ever been munching on some spicy buffalo wings at your favorite sports bar and suddenly thought, “Wait, why the heck are these called buffalo chicken anyway?” I mean, they’re clearly not made from buffalo meat (thank goodness!), so what’s the deal with the name?
Well, I’ve done some digging, and the answer is actually pretty straightforward – though there’s more to the story than you might expect. Let’s dive into the saucy origins of this American classic that’s become a staple at every Super Bowl party and sports gathering across the nation.
The Origin: It’s All About Location, Location, Location
Buffalo chicken gets its name directly from its birthplace Buffalo, New York. Yep, it’s that simple! The dish originated in this city located in western New York state, not from some strange chicken-buffalo hybrid animal (which was honestly my first thought as a kid)
But the story behind how these wings became a national obsession? That’s where things get interesting – and a bit controversial.
The Anchor Bar Story: The Most Popular Origin Tale
The most widely accepted story traces buffalo wings back to the Anchor Bar in Buffalo, New York. According to this version, it all started one fateful night in 1964 when Teressa Bellissimo, co-owner of the establishment, needed to whip up a quick midnight snack.
Here’s how the story goes:
Teressa’s son Dominic showed up at the bar late one night with some hungry college friends. Being the good mom that she was, Teressa wanted to feed them something tasty. Instead of using the chicken wings for soup stock (which was typically their fate back then), she had a stroke of genius.
She:
- Deep-fried the wings
- Tossed them in a special hot sauce (reportedly based on Frank’s RedHot Sauce)
- Served them with celery sticks and blue cheese dressing
Voilà! Buffalo wings were born.
But wait – there’s more than one version of even this story!
The Conflicting Anchor Bar Tales
Even within the Anchor Bar origin story, details get fuzzy. In fact, there are at least three different versions:
Version 1: The “Accidental Shipment” story claims the Anchor Bar accidentally received a shipment of wings instead of the chicken backs and necks they had ordered for making spaghetti sauce. Not wanting to waste food, Teressa got creative.
Version 2: The “Late-Night Snack” version (which I mentioned above) where Dominic and his college buddies needed food after a night of drinking.
Version 3: Dominic himself told the New Yorker in 1980 that it was actually his father Frank who wanted to do something nice for bar patrons at midnight on a Friday night when Catholic customers would be able to eat meat again. Teressa fried up the leftover wings and tossed them in that now-famous sauce.
Honestly, with all these versions floating around, it makes me wonder if anyone really remembers exactly what happened that night!
The John Young Controversy: The Forgotten Pioneer?
Here’s where the story gets even more interesting – and points to an often overlooked part of culinary history.
According to some accounts, a Black chef named John Young had been cooking up his own version of chicken wings in Buffalo for years before the Anchor Bar claimed to have invented them. His restaurant, “John Young’s Wings ‘n Things,” was serving breaded, fried chicken wings with a special “mombo sauce” as early as 1960.
Some reports suggest that the Bellissimos and other local restaurateurs had actually visited Young’s establishment before “inventing” their own version. Young’s wings were served whole with his spicy-tangy-sweet orange-red sauce, while the Anchor Bar’s innovation was breaking the wings into flats and drumettes and tossing them directly in a buttery hot sauce.
This part of the story highlights how often Black culinary contributions have been erased from food history – something we’re only now starting to address in the culinary world.
What Makes Buffalo Sauce So Special?
Whatever the true origin story, one thing’s for sure – that sauce is what makes buffalo chicken, well, buffalo chicken!
Traditional buffalo sauce is a simple but magical mixture of:
- Hot pepper sauce (typically Frank’s RedHot)
- Melted butter
- Sometimes a touch of vinegar or Worcestershire sauce
The butter is what gives the sauce its distinct richness and helps it cling to the wings. The ratio of hot sauce to butter determines how spicy the wings will be – more butter makes for a milder experience, while more hot sauce cranks up the heat.
The Perfect Companions: Why Blue Cheese and Celery?
Ever wondered why buffalo wings are traditionally served with blue cheese dressing and celery sticks? It’s not just random!
The cool, creamy blue cheese provides a perfect contrast to the spicy wings. The tanginess of the cheese complements the acidity of the sauce, while providing a cooling effect for your burning taste buds. Meanwhile, the crisp celery adds a refreshing crunch that balances out the rich, spicy wings.
It’s literally a perfect flavor trio – though I know some people who swear by ranch dressing instead of blue cheese (a controversial stance in some wing circles!).
From Local Favorite to National Phenomenon
Buffalo wings didn’t immediately take off nationwide. They remained primarily a local specialty in upstate New York until the late 1970s and early 1980s.
The popularity explosion seems to have happened due to a few factors:
-
Sports connection: The Buffalo Bills’ success in the early 1990s (making it to four consecutive Super Bowls) helped bring national attention to the city’s signature dish.
-
Chain restaurants: Places like Buffalo Wild Wings (founded 1982) and Hooters began popularizing the dish across the country.
-
Fast food adoption: By the 1990s, even McDonald’s had added “Mighty Wings” to their menu, and Domino’s and Pizza Hut soon followed suit.
Today, Americans consume more than 1.4 BILLION wings during Super Bowl weekend alone, according to the National Chicken Council. That’s a lotta wings!
Beyond Wings: The Buffalo-ification of Everything
These days, the term “buffalo” has transcended the wing to become a flavor profile all its own. You can find buffalo-style:
- Chicken sandwiches
- Pizza
- Dips
- Cauliflower (for the vegetarians!)
- Shrimp
- Salads
- Even sushi!
The spicy, tangy, buttery sauce has become so iconic that it’s now a standard flavor option for practically anything savory. I personally draw the line at buffalo ice cream, but I wouldn’t be shocked if someone’s tried it!
Making Buffalo Chicken at Home
Want to create authentic buffalo flavor at home? Here’s a super simple recipe for classic buffalo sauce:
Basic Buffalo Sauce:
- 2/3 cup hot pepper sauce (Frank’s RedHot is traditional)
- 1/2 cup unsalted butter
- 1 tablespoon white vinegar
- 1/4 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce
- 1/4 teaspoon garlic powder
- Salt to taste
Just melt the butter, whisk in the other ingredients, and you’re good to go! Toss with fried or baked chicken wings, or use it on whatever protein you prefer.
Buffalo Wings Around the World
The popularity of buffalo wings has spread far beyond American borders. You can now find buffalo wings on menus across the globe, though the interpretations sometimes vary wildly from the original.
Buffalo, NY is understandably proud of its culinary contribution to the world. The city has celebrated Chicken Wing Day every July since 1970, hosts an annual National Buffalo Wing Festival, and even has a National Buffalo Wing “Hall of Flame” (see what they did there?).
FAQs About Buffalo Chicken
Are buffalo wings always deep-fried?
Traditionally yes, but nowadays many people bake, air-fry, or grill their wings for a healthier alternative. The key is getting that crispy exterior before adding the sauce.
What’s the difference between buffalo wings and hot wings?
Buffalo wings specifically refer to wings coated in the classic Frank’s RedHot-based sauce. “Hot wings” can be any type of spicy chicken wing, regardless of the sauce used.
Can vegetarians enjoy buffalo flavor?
Absolutely! Cauliflower wings are a super popular vegetarian alternative. Just bread and roast cauliflower florets until crispy, then toss in buffalo sauce.
What drinks pair best with buffalo wings?
Beer (especially lagers and pale ales) is the classic pairing, but any cold, refreshing beverage works well to combat the heat. Some people swear by Riesling wine or even lemonade.
The Bottom Line
So there you have it – buffalo chicken is called “buffalo” simply because it originated in Buffalo, New York. Whether you believe the Anchor Bar story, think John Young deserves more credit, or suspect the truth lies somewhere in between, one thing’s certain: this fiery, flavorful dish has secured its place in American food history.
The next time you’re enjoying some spicy buffalo goodness, you can impress your friends with this tasty bit of food trivia. Just maybe don’t start the “ranch vs. blue cheese” debate unless you’re prepared for some heated opinions!
What’s your favorite way to enjoy buffalo chicken? Are you a traditionalist who only wants the wings, or do you embrace buffalo everything? Drop a comment below – I’d love to know!
Once Upon A Time in Buffalo, New Yorkâ¦
In 1964, the Anchor Bar in Buffalo, New York was faced with a problem. The family-owned and operated business had a surplus of chicken wings in their kitchen, and they werenât quite sure what to do with them. Bar owner Teresa Bellissimo had an idea: What if she deep-fried the wings, covered them with hot sauce, and served them with blue cheese dressing? This impromptu recipe would form the foundation of buffalo wings as we know them today, and they quickly exploded in popularity after their inception. Bellissimoâs recipe would soon be called âBuffalo Chicken Wingsâ after the city from which they originated: Buffalo, New York.
How Buffalo Wings Spread Beyond Buffalo
For the next few years, buffalo wings would largely remain a regional dish that could only be found in the state of New York. After all, what better way to spend the cold winter months than by feasting on some hot and spicy wings? However, like many delicious food items, the recipe for buffalo wings was taken abroad, and restaurants all along the East Coast began serving their own hot wings. By the 1990s, wing restaurants could be found all over the country, and several new wing flavors were developed to accommodate the different tastes of each region. Sure, you could still get classic Buffalo wings, but new flavors such as BBQ, teriyaki, and garlic parmesan allowed customers to mix and match their favorites.Â