Where To Buy Mushrooms That Taste Like Chicken: The Ultimate Guide for Meat-Free Alternatives

Are you craving that familiar chicken flavor but trying to cut back on meat? Or maybe you’re a vegetarian looking for convincing alternatives that don’t compromise on taste? Well, you’re in luck! There’s a whole kingdom of mushrooms out there that can trick your taste buds into thinking you’re eating chicken.

In this guide, I’ll walk you through everything you need to know about chicken-flavored mushrooms – from which varieties to look for to where you can buy them. Trust me, after reading this, you’ll be ready to transform your plant-based cooking game!

Which Mushroom Varieties Taste Like Chicken?

Let’s start by identifying the main mushroom contenders that have earned a reputation for their chicken-like qualities:

1. Oyster Mushrooms (The Reigning Champion)

Oyster mushrooms (Pleurotus ostreatus) are widely considered the top choice when you’re looking for a chicken substitute. These delicate-looking fungi pack a surprising punch in terms of texture and flavor.

Why oyster mushrooms work well as chicken substitutes:

• They have a mild, savory flavor that becomes more pronounced when cooked
• Their delicate, slightly chewy texture mimics chicken quite well
• They easily absorb flavors from marinades and seasonings
• They’re widely available year-round

When properly prepared, oyster mushrooms develop an umami richness that closely resembles poultry. Their versatility makes them perfect for nearly any dish that calls for chicken.

2. Chicken of the Woods (The Natural Impersonator)

With a name like “Chicken of the Woods” (Laetiporus sulphureus), you know this mushroom means business when it comes to mimicking poultry

Key characteristics

• Bright yellow to orange coloration
• Grows on trees, particularly oak
• Available fresh from August through November
• Has a tender texture similar to chicken breast
• When cooked, develops a flavor profile remarkably similar to chicken

This mushroom is especially prized by foragers and wild food enthusiasts. It can be prepared in most ways you’d prepare chicken meat and works wonderfully as a direct substitute in vegetarian diets.

3. King Oyster Mushrooms (The Meaty Alternative)

King oyster mushrooms (Pleurotus eryngii) are the larger cousins of regular oyster mushrooms, and they offer an even meatier experience.

What makes them special:

• Large, thick stems with small caps
• Substantial, meaty bite
• Develops savory umami flavor with hints of nuttiness when cooked
• Firm yet tender texture
• Available year-round in many grocery stores

The thick stems of king oyster mushrooms can be sliced into medallions that look and feel surprisingly like chicken when cooked.

4. Other Honorable Mentions

While the above three are your best bets for chicken flavor, there are a few other mushrooms worth considering:

• Lion’s Mane (Hericium erinaceus): Has a stringy texture that can mimic shredded chicken
• Maitake/Hen of the Woods: Some describe the flavor as chicken-like
• Shiitake Mushrooms: While earthier than others, can work in dishes where subtle chicken flavor is desired

Where To Buy Mushrooms That Taste Like Chicken

Now that we know what we’re looking for, let’s explore where you can actually purchase these fantastic fungi:

Grocery Stores and Supermarkets

Most well-stocked grocery stores now carry at least some variety of specialty mushrooms:

• Mainstream grocery chains (Kroger, Safeway, etc.): Look for oyster and king oyster mushrooms in the produce section
• Health food stores (Whole Foods, etc.): Often carry a wider variety of specialty mushrooms
• Asian markets: Excellent source for oyster and king oyster mushrooms, often at better prices than conventional stores

Farmers Markets

Farmers markets are treasure troves for fresh, locally-grown mushrooms:

• You can speak directly with growers about their cultivation practices
• Mushrooms are typically fresher than store-bought options
• You might find seasonal varieties like Chicken of the Woods that rarely appear in conventional stores
• Prices can be better than specialty shops for certain varieties

Online Retailers

The internet has made specialty mushrooms accessible to everyone, regardless of location:

For Fresh Mushrooms:

• Oregon Mushrooms: Ships fresh Chicken of the Woods overnight when in season ($24 per pound)
• Fungi Perfecti: Offers foraged wild mushrooms including Chicken of the Woods
• Earthy Delights: Specializes in gourmet and wild mushrooms

For Dried Mushrooms:

• Oregon Mushrooms: Sells dried Chicken of the Woods year-round
• Mushroom House: Offers dried pieces and powders of various chicken-like mushrooms
• Nuts.com: Carries dried specialty mushrooms
• Amazon: Various vendors sell dried mushroom varieties
• Hole in the Woods Farm: Forages and dries Chicken of the Woods

Specialty and Gourmet Shops

Don’t overlook local specialty food stores:

• Gourmet shops often carry fresh and dried specialty mushrooms
• Health food stores frequently stock mushroom varieties not found in conventional markets
• Some cheese shops and delis carry specialty mushrooms

Grow Your Own

For the ambitious home cook, growing your own mushrooms is actually quite doable:

• Pre-inoculated kits are available online and at garden centers
• Oyster mushrooms are among the easiest varieties to grow at home
• Growing your own ensures freshness and organic status
• It’s more economical in the long run for regular consumers

Price Expectations

When shopping for these specialty mushrooms, here’s what you can expect to pay:

Preparing Your Chicken-Like Mushrooms

Once you’ve sourced your mushrooms, here are some tips to maximize their chicken-like qualities:

Cooking Techniques

1. Searing for Texture: Sear oyster mushrooms in a hot pan with oil to create a crispy exterior similar to fried chicken.

2. Marinating for Flavor: Soak mushrooms in a mixture containing:

   • Soy sauce or tamari
   • Garlic and ginger
   • Smoked paprika
   • A touch of poultry seasoning

3. Shredding for Versatility: Tear or shred oyster mushrooms with forks before cooking to replicate the texture of pulled chicken.

4. Using the Right Spices: Don’t be shy with seasonings! Poultry seasoning, onion powder, garlic powder, and even a touch of liquid smoke can enhance the chicken-like profile.

Recipe Ideas

These mushrooms shine in recipes like:

• Vegan “chicken” sandwiches
• Mushroom “chicken” pot pie
• Tacos and burritos
• Stir-fries and noodle dishes
• Soups and stews
• “Chicken” nuggets or tenders

Storage Tips

To get the most from your specialty mushrooms:

• Fresh mushrooms: Store in a paper bag (not plastic!) in the refrigerator and use within a week
• Cleaning: Gently wipe with a damp cloth rather than soaking in water
• Freezing: Cook mushrooms before freezing for best texture
• Dried mushrooms: Store in airtight containers in a cool, dark place

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these mushrooms safe to eat?

Generally, yes, especially when purchased from reputable sources. However, with Chicken of the Woods specifically, it’s important to note that this mushroom occasionally causes gastric distress in some individuals. It’s recommended to try a small amount first if you’ve never had it before.

Can I forage for these mushrooms myself?

While foraging is possible, EXTREME caution is advised. Mushroom misidentification can be dangerous or even fatal. Always go with experienced foragers and never eat a wild mushroom unless you are 100% certain of its identification.

What if I can’t find fresh mushrooms?

Dried versions work well too! Rehydrate them in warm water before using. The flavor is often more concentrated in dried mushrooms.

Are these mushrooms nutritious?

Yes! Mushrooms like oyster varieties are good sources of protein, fiber, vitamins, and minerals. They’re also low in calories and fat, making them a healthy addition to your diet.

Conclusion

Finding mushrooms that taste like chicken is easier than ever before. Whether you prefer shopping at your local grocery store, farmers market, or online, there are plenty of options available to satisfy your cravings without compromising on taste or texture.

The next time you’re thinking about making your favorite chicken dish, consider swapping in one of these magical mushrooms. Your taste buds—and maybe even your chickens—will thank you!

Have you tried cooking with mushrooms as a chicken substitute? What was your experience like? I’d love to hear your thoughts and recipes in the comments section below!

---

This article was last updated on September 12, 2025. Availability and prices of mushrooms may vary by season and location.