Ever stared at your beautifully breaded chicken cutlets and wondered what sauce would take your chicken parm from good to absolutely mind-blowing? I’ve been there too! After years of experimenting in my kitchen (and eating way too much chicken parmesan in the process), I’m excited to share everything I’ve learned about the perfect sauces for this Italian-American classic.
The Classic Champion: Marinara Sauce
Without a doubt, marinara sauce reigns supreme when it comes to chicken parmesan. There’s a reason this pairing has stood the test of time! A vibrant, tomato-based marinara provides the perfect balance of acidity, sweetness, and herbal notes that complement the crispy chicken and melted cheese.
What makes marinara so perfect? Unlike heavier sauces like bolognese (which contains meat) or cream-based sauces, marinara is lighter and brighter. It enhances rather than masks the delicate flavors of your perfectly cooked chicken.
Making Your Own Marinara Magic
If you’ve got the time homemade marinara is absolutely worth the effort. Here’s my simple approach
- Start with high-quality San Marzano tomatoes (they’re seriously game-changing)
- Sauté garlic gently in olive oil (but don’t burn it or you’ll get bitterness!)
- Simmer low and slow for at least an hour (patience pays off!)
- Add fresh herbs toward the end (preserves their vibrant flavor)
- Balance acidity with a tiny pinch of sugar if needed
The “low and slow” approach allows all those flavors to meld together beautifully. Trust me, you’ll taste the difference!
Best Store-Bought Marinara Options
Let’s be real – sometimes we don’t have hours to simmer sauce. When I need a quality store-bought option, these are my go-tos:
- Rao’s Homemade Marinara – Consistently rated as the closest to homemade by most chefs
- Mezzetta Napa Valley Homemade Marinara – Great balance of flavors
- Victoria White Linen Marinara – Simple, clean ingredients
- Muir Glen Organic Tomato Basil – Excellent organic option
When selecting a store-bought marinara, I always check the ingredients list The best options have simple, recognizable ingredients and no added sugar or preservatives
Beyond Marinara: Alternative Sauce Options
While marinara is the traditional choice, there’s room for creativity! Here are some other sauces that work surprisingly well:
Arrabbiata Sauce
If you like a bit of heat, arrabbiata is essentially marinara with added chili peppers. The spicy kick creates an interesting contrast with the rich, melty cheese. Just be mindful of your spice tolerance!
Basic Tomato Sauce
Sometimes simpler is better A basic tomato sauce with minimal seasoning lets the chicken and cheese flavors shine through It’s less complex than marinara but still delivers that essential tomato foundation.
Puttanesca (For the Adventurous)
With its briny olives, capers, and anchovies, puttanesca offers a boldly different flavor profile. I’ll admit this is a controversial choice – some people love it, others find it overpowers the dish. If you’re feeling adventurous, give it a try!
What About Alfredo or Cream-Based Sauces?
I’ve seen some recipes suggesting alfredo sauce for chicken parm, and while it’s certainly rich and delicious, it creates an entirely different dish. The heavy cream can clash with the acidity of the tomatoes if you’re still using them underneath the chicken, and the result can be overwhelmingly rich.
That said, a “Chicken Parmesan Alfredo” variation (skipping the tomato sauce entirely) can be a delicious alternative for cream sauce lovers.
Store-Bought Sauce Hacks: Making It Your Own
Even when using jarred sauce, I like to doctor it up a bit to make it taste more homemade:
- Sauté some fresh garlic and onions before adding the jarred sauce
- Add a splash of red wine for depth
- Throw in fresh herbs like basil in the last few minutes
- A tablespoon of butter can add richness and cut acidity
- A pinch of red pepper flakes adds a nice subtle heat
These simple additions take just a few minutes but make a big difference in the final flavor!
FAQs About Chicken Parm Sauces
Can I use canned tomatoes instead of jarred sauce?
Absolutely! High-quality canned San Marzano tomatoes are excellent and often preferred by chefs. They’re more versatile than pre-made sauce and allow you to control the seasonings.
How long should I simmer my sauce?
Ideally, simmer your marinara for at least one hour, though 2-3 hours will develop even richer flavors. The longer cooking time allows the flavors to meld beautifully.
Should I add sugar to my sauce?
A tiny pinch of sugar can help balance the acidity of tomatoes, especially if they’re particularly tart. Start with just a pinch and adjust to taste.
Can I make the sauce ahead of time?
Not only can you, but you should! Marinara sauce actually improves with age. Making it a day or two ahead allows the flavors to develop even further.
What’s the difference between marinara and spaghetti sauce?
Marinara is generally simpler, focusing primarily on tomatoes, garlic, and herbs. Spaghetti sauce often includes meat, additional vegetables, and a wider variety of seasonings.
Keeping Your Chicken Crispy
One challenge with chicken parm is keeping the chicken crispy once the sauce is added. Here are my tips:
- Don’t add sauce until just before serving
- Consider placing the sauce underneath the chicken rather than on top
- If adding sauce on top, do it just before adding cheese and broiling
- Use a wire rack after frying to maintain crispness
The Perfect Cheese Combo
While we’re focused on sauce here, I can’t ignore the importance of cheese! The traditional combo is:
- Mozzarella for that perfect melty, stretchy quality
- Parmesan for sharp, salty flavor
- Some recipes add provolone for extra flavor dimension
Final Thoughts: It’s All About Balance
The perfect chicken parm is about balance – crispy chicken, tangy sauce, and melty cheese. The sauce shouldn’t overwhelm but rather complement the other elements.
While I’ve given you my recommendations, the best sauce is ultimately the one you enjoy most! Don’t be afraid to experiment and find your personal chicken parm perfection.
Cart0 items
Sorry, looks like we dont have enough of this product. Your cart is currently empty.
Tips: The marinara sauce can be made a day ahead of time. It can also be made on its own and used as a pasta sauce. When tenderizing the meat, it is important to start in the center and work your way out to the edges. This gives you more control and helps to keep the thickness of the tenderized meat consistent. The chicken is tenderized so that it cooks consistently and quickly, and so that the frying is consistent. This way you get a nice, even golden brown color and great flavor without burning or under or overcooking.