Let’s face it – chicken pot pie is comfort food at its finest. That golden, flaky crust hiding a creamy, savory filling… it’s enough to make anyone’s mouth water! But have you ever sat down with this delicious dish and thought, “Wait, am I eating this right?” If so, you’re not alone.
I’ve been enjoying chicken pot pies for years, and I’ve picked up some tricks along the way that I’m excited to share with you. Whether you’re dining at a fancy restaurant or cozied up at home with a homemade or store-bought pie, these tips will help you enjoy every last morsel without making a mess or committing any pot pie faux pas.
Setting the Stage for Pot Pie Success
Before you even take your first bite there are a few preliminary steps that can significantly enhance your pot pie experience.
Temperature Matters
One of the biggest mistakes people make is diving in too quickly. A pot pie fresh from the oven is tempting, but its molten core can be dangerous!
Allow your pot pie to cool slightly before digging in. Aim for a temperature where the crust is warm and inviting, but the filling won’t scald your tongue. This cooling period (usually 5-7 minutes) also allows the flavors to meld and the filling to thicken slightly.
Think of it like easing yourself into a hot tub rather than jumping in – one approach is pleasant, the other painful!
The Great Utensil Debate: Fork vs. Spoon
This is perhaps the most contentious issue in pot pie etiquette: should you use a fork, a spoon, or both?
The truth is, there’s no definitive right answer. Each utensil offers advantages:
-
Fork: Allows for more delicate and controlled crust management. Perfect for those who enjoy a balanced ratio of crust to filling in each bite.
-
Spoon: Ideal for scooping up generous portions of the creamy filling, ensuring you don’t miss a single morsel of savory goodness.
-
The dual-wielding approach Many pot pie enthusiasts (myself included) prefer using both – fork for breaking the crust and spoon for the filling
Experiment and find what works best for you! At formal dinners, you might want to start with a fork and knife to break the crust, then transition to a spoon for the filling.
Optional Enhancements
While a perfect chicken pot pie needs no embellishment, certain accompaniments can elevate the experience:
- A simple side salad with light vinaigrette provides refreshing contrast
- A dollop of sour cream or plain yogurt adds tangy coolness
- A sprinkle of fresh herbs like parsley or thyme brightens the flavors
Just remember – the pot pie should remain the star of the show!
Conquering the Crust: Strategic Approaches
The crust is the gateway to pot pie paradise. How you approach it sets the tone for your entire dining experience.
Finding Your Perfect Crust-to-Filling Ratio
Everyone has preferences here. Some people love the flaky, buttery crust and want to savor every bit. Others see it merely as a vehicle for the creamy filling inside. Both approaches are valid!
A well-crafted pot pie offers balance – the crust should be sturdy enough to contain the filling but tender enough to yield easily to your utensil. It should complement the filling without overpowering it.
Strategic Entry Points
Resist the urge to smash the crust into smithereens! Instead, approach with finesse:
- Begin by creating a small opening in the center of the crust
- This allows steam to escape and prevents potential eruptions of scalding filling
- From there, you can either:
- Work methodically around the perimeter
- Create several strategic openings to access different layers of filling
Using the Crust as a Natural Vessel
One of my favorite techniques involves using the crust as an edible spoon. After creating an opening, use pieces of crust to scoop up portions of the filling. This provides a satisfying textural contrast and lets you control the ratio of crust to filling in each bite.
Just be careful not to overload your crust “spoon” or you might experience structural collapse!
Navigating the Filling: The Heart of the Pot Pie
The filling is the soul of any chicken pot pie – a complex tapestry of flavors and textures that defines the dish.
Identifying the Key Players
A classic chicken pot pie typically features:
- Tender chunks of chicken
- A medley of vegetables (carrots, peas, potatoes)
- Rich, creamy sauce
Each ingredient contributes to the overall experience. The chicken provides savory foundation, vegetables add sweetness and earthiness, and the sauce binds everything together.
The Art of the Swirl
Don’t just eat the filling in distinct layers! Instead, try the “swirl” technique – gently stirring the filling to combine different ingredients. This ensures each bite delivers a symphony of flavors rather than isolated components.
The swirl technique also helps distribute heat evenly, preventing surprise pockets of scalding filling. It’s a simple yet effective way to enhance your pot pie enjoyment.
Embracing the Unexpected
Some of the best bites are the ones you don’t plan for – a perfectly browned chunk of chicken, a burst of sweetness from a hidden pea, a surprising hint of thyme. These little surprises often make the biggest impact, so remain open to the pot pie’s serendipitous moments!
Advanced Pot Pie Techniques for Connoisseurs
Once you’ve mastered the basics, you might want to explore some advanced techniques to further elevate your pot pie experience.
The Deconstruction Method
For devoted crust lovers, try carefully removing the entire top crust in one piece (or as close as possible) and consuming it separately. This allows you to savor its flaky, buttery goodness in its purest form.
Once the crust is gone, you can focus solely on the filling, enjoying the unadulterated flavors. This method isn’t for everyone, but it offers a unique experience for the truly dedicated.
The Layered Approach
Instead of swirling the filling, try eating it in distinct layers:
- Start with the top layer (typically the richest sauce)
- Work your way down through the vegetables and chicken
- Finish with the bottom crust, which has often absorbed delicious flavors
This allows you to appreciate different textures and flavors individually, creating a more nuanced experience.
The Bottom-Up Assault
Most people eat pot pie from the top down, but there’s something to be said for starting from the bottom. This unconventional approach lets you access the deepest, most flavorful layers first, saving the golden crust for last.
This can be especially rewarding if the bottom crust has become infused with savory juices from the filling. It’s an adventurous move that can yield delicious results!
Reheating Chicken Pot Pie Without Ruining the Crust
If you’re enjoying leftover pot pie (sometimes even better than the first day!), proper reheating is crucial.
The oven is your best friend here. Preheat to 350°F, cover the pot pie loosely with foil, and bake for 15-20 minutes. Remove the foil for the last few minutes to crisp up the crust.
Avoid microwaving if possible – it’ll leave you with a soggy, disappointing crust. If you’re really in a hurry, try an air fryer set to 320°F for 8-10 minutes, which can yield surprisingly good results.
Pot Pie Etiquette for Different Settings
Your approach might vary depending on where you’re enjoying your pot pie:
At Home
Feel free to use whatever utensils you prefer and get as messy as you want! This is the place to try those more adventurous techniques without judgment.
At a Casual Restaurant
A fork and spoon combination works well here. Start with the fork to break the crust, then switch to the spoon for the filling.
At a Formal Dinner
Individual ramekins are often served at formal occasions, making the experience more manageable. Use a fork and knife to break the crust initially, then a spoon for the filling. Take smaller, more controlled bites and be mindful of potential drips.
Pairing Suggestions to Enhance Your Pot Pie
The right beverage can elevate your pot pie experience:
-
Wine: Crisp, dry white wines with good acidity (Chardonnay, Pinot Grigio, Sauvignon Blanc) cut through the richness. If you prefer red, try a light-bodied Pinot Noir.
-
Beer: A medium-bodied amber ale or brown ale complements the savory flavors without overwhelming them.
-
Non-alcoholic: Sparkling water with a squeeze of lemon provides refreshing contrast, or try unsweetened iced tea.
Adapting These Techniques for Different Pot Pie Styles
These guidelines work for most pot pies, but you may need to adjust based on specific styles:
-
Deep dish pies: Require more strategic planning – consider creating a “well” in the center first, then working outward.
-
Individual pot pies: Easier to manage but cook more quickly, so be extra careful about temperature.
-
Puff pastry topped pies: The crust is more delicate, so handle with care to preserve those beautiful flaky layers.
-
Vegetarian pot pies: Same techniques apply, but filling might have different consistency depending on protein substitutes.
The Aftermath: A Pot Pie Well Eaten
A clean plate is the ultimate sign of pot pie success! That warm, satisfied feeling after finishing a delicious pot pie is what I call the “post-pot pie glow” – a genuine sense of contentment that only comfort food can provide.
Remember, the “correct” way to eat chicken pot pie is ultimately the way that brings you the most joy. Experiment with different techniques, explore new flavors, and continue refining your approach with each delicious pie.
Whether you’re a fork purist, a spoon enthusiast, or a dual-wielding pot pie professional, the most important thing is to savor every bite of this classic comfort food. After all, isn’t enjoyment what comfort food is all about?
What’s your favorite way to eat chicken pot pie? I’d love to hear your techniques in the comments below!
Sign up for Eater’s newsletter
The freshest news from the food world every dayEmail (required)By submitting your email, you agree to our
What Most People Get Wrong About Chicken Pot Pie
FAQ
What is the proper way to eat a chicken pot pie?
You typically eat chicken pot pie with a fork. The crust can be flaky and the filling is often thick, making a fork the best choice for cutting through the pastry and scooping up the filling.
Do you eat chicken pot pie with a fork or spoon?
You typically eat chicken pot pie with a fork if it’s a traditional meat pie with a solid crust, but you use a spoon if it’s a Pennsylvania Dutch pot pie, which is more like a stew with noodles or dumplings, or if the filling is particularly runny. Many people use both a fork and spoon together, or a fork for the solid ingredients and a spoon for the broth.
What do you eat with a chicken pot pie?
Serve chicken pot pie with light, contrasting sides such as a crisp green salad, steamed or roasted vegetables like green beans or broccoli, or a sweet and tart fruit salad to balance its richness. Classic bread choices like dinner rolls or garlic bread, and creamy mashed potatoes are also popular pairings that complement the savory flavors.