Ever been to Red Lobster? Ever tasted the fine delicacy that is a Cheddar Bay Biscuit, or the sweet magic of Endless Shrimp? If so, youre probably as hooked on the fine foods that come in those checker-lined baskets as I am. And heres the thing: you and me? We arent the only ones.
A quick browse of Reddit Lobster (a mecca for all things Red Lobster on Reddit.com) will show that there are a few little-known tidbits that Red Lobster employees want to get out in the open. Now employees are taking to the AMA threads to let die-hard RL fans pick their brains (just not their baskets. What monster shares fried shrimp?). The next time youre thinking about sliding into the booth for a basket of that famous Red Lobster shrimp, better commit these facts to memory first.
Red Lobster is practically synonymous with indulgent seafood, especially juicy, butter-drenched lobster As a lifelong lobster lover, I’ve always wondered – can you actually select your own live lobster from the tank at Red Lobster?
It turns out the ability to choose your own lobster at America’s largest casual dining seafood chain comes with some caveats Here’s the inside scoop on how lobster selection works at Red Lobster restaurants
Do All Red Lobster Locations Have Lobster Tanks?
The first step to picking your own lobster is finding a restaurant that actually displays live lobsters. However, not every Red Lobster location has a dedicated lobster tank.
Red Lobster restaurants range in size and format. Larger, busier urban and tourist-focused locations are more likely to invest in showcasing live lobsters. Smaller or lower volume restaurants probably won’t have space for a lobster tank.
Your best bet for finding live lobsters on display is to visit a big, high-traffic Red Lobster location downtown or in a heavily touristed area. Call ahead to confirm they have a lobster tank on site if hand selecting your crustacean is a priority.
Can You Simply Point Out a Lobster to Be Cooked?
You find a Red Lobster with live lobsters on display. Can you just tap on the tank glass and request that specific lobster for your dinner?
Unfortunately, it’s not quite that easy. Here’s how lobster selection typically works:
-
The lobster tank is primarily for display rather than active selection. It shows customers the freshness of the seafood.
-
Kitchen staff periodically harvest multiple lobsters from the tank that have reached an optimal size for cooking.
-
The harvested lobsters are grouped together in a holding tank, no longer identified individually.
-
When you order a steamed lobster, one of these previously harvested lobsters is selected at random to fill your order.
So while you can admire the live lobster tank, you likely can’t single out one specific lobster to end up on your plate.
Politely Ask If You Can Select After Harvesting
While pointing out a lobster from the main display tank may not be possible, you may be able to select one freshly harvested for cooking.
Here’s how to nicely ask if you can hand-pick your lobster:
-
When ordering, politely ask your server, “I noticed you have live lobster tanks. I’m so excited to try it! Is there any way I could possibly choose my own lobster after they are gathered from the tank?”
-
Emphasize you don’t wish to inconvenience them if it’s not possible. You’re just curious as a lobster enthusiast.
-
If approved, the manager may allow you to briefly select from harvested lobsters before cooking.
The staff wants you to have an amazing dining experience, so politely asking can’t hurt! The worst they can say is no.
Order “Fresh from the Tank”
One insider tip is to specifically order your lobster “fresh from the tank.” This signals to the kitchen your desire for the absolute freshest lobster.
While you still can’t hand-select, ordering “fresh from the tank” means they’ll grab the first freshly harvested lobster ready for steaming. This helps ensure your lobster is cooked right after being pulled from the tank. They may even time the harvesting around your order!
Why Individual Selection is Limited
While choosing your personal lobster sounds fun, there are some valid reasons why the process is restricted at chains like Red Lobster:
-
Allowing every lobster order to hand-pick would be incredibly time consuming, slowing service especially during busy rushes.
-
Workers can get pinched or nipped by lobsters rapidly snatched from tanks.
-
There aren’t proper food safety protocols for customers sticking hands into live lobster tanks.
-
Tanks aren’t divided into separate enclosures for each lobster.
-
Staff don’t track lobsters as individuals since they’re commodities rather than pets.
For these reasons, Red Lobster opts to harvest lobsters in batches versus filling individual orders. But you can still request the freshest possible lobster for your meal!
Enjoy Your Red Lobster Lobster Feast
While you may not be able to select every detail, take time to savor Red Lobster’s succulent lobster sensations. The display tanks still assure freshness of the seafood. And asking politely about selecting after harvesting, or ordering “fresh from the tank,” can potentially get your lobster as close to your ideal as possible.
So next time you visit Red Lobster, indulge in tender bites of lobster prepared by the seafood experts. Catching a glimpse of the live lobster tank is just an appetizer before the main event – devouring sweet, delicate lobster!
You Can Order Food That Is No Longer On The Menu
There arent any secret menu items on the Red Lobster menu, but one former employee told Reddit users that customers are “able to order items that we have had previously on the menu but that have since been removed, so long as the ingredients have not been removed from our menu.”
They Always Bring One Extra Biscuit To The Table For A Reason
Have you ever wondered why every table gets an odd number of biscuits, with one extra biscuit, no matter what? A former employee explained on Reddit that its actually corporate policy to bring one extra biscuit to the table. Another user added, Weve been told that the first basket with the extra piece is a conversation starter and thats why we do it.”
We Ate the Most EXPENSIVE Seafood at Red Lobster
FAQ
Can I pick my lobster at Red Lobster?
You can get whole live Maines all year round at Red Lobster. They are kept in the lobster tanks in the front lobby and you can even pick your’s out if you so choose.
Does Red Lobster do pickup orders?
By signing up for the Red Lobster Curbside Pickup Alert Text Program (“Program”), you agree to these terms and conditions (“Program Terms”) and our general Terms of Use, consent to our practices described herein and in our Privacy Notice and authorize Red Lobster Management LLC (“Red Lobster” “us” “we” or “us”) to …
How much is a full lobster usually?
The price of live lobsters can be significantly less than that of lobster meat, depending mostly on the type and origin of the lobster. For instance, the price of live whole lobsters may range between $35 and $50 per pound, while lobster tail meat may cost between $55 and $75 per pound.
Does Red Lobster have seafood?
Red Lobster’s menu has a wide range of fresh, high-quality seafood options, as well as non-seafood choices for those who prefer meat. From classic shrimp and lobster dishes to unique signature items, there’s something for everyone.
Can I order Red Lobster If I have a food allergy?
Before placing your order, please see our allergen guide if a member of your party has a food allergy. Order Red Lobster delivery online. Find your favorite items from the Red Lobster signature feasts menu, including our Create Your Own Ultimate Feast®.
How do I find a Red Lobster restaurant near me?
Using your current location you can search the near by Red Lobster restaurant on their website. You can also search through city or zip code. Most restaurants of Red Lobster follow regular opening times, that is, 11 am to 10 pm.
Is Red Lobster a good restaurant?
Red Lobster is an American restaurant chain with the aim of offering sea food which is not only high quality but also affordable. It was family-owned restaurant initially and later multiplied rapidly from coast to coast.
Why should you choose Red Lobster?
For more than five decades Red Lobster has been a part of your family’s life. We’ve been there for your celebrations, big and small. We may be the place that you first discovered your love of seafood. Or where you met the love of your life on a first date. Birthdays, graduations, anniversaries and yes, weddings. We’ve been here for them all.
Does Red Lobster have a logo?
Red Lobster trademarks and logos are the sole property of their respective owners. For the most accurate and current information, please visit the official Red Lobster website. See the Red lobster menu with prices and pictures. Explore Family Meals, Starters, and Desserts Accurate and updated for 2025.