Hey there! I’m a seafood enthusiast and professional food writer who’s spent years working with various types of shrimp. Today, I’m gonna break down everything you need to know about cocktail shrimp sizes in simple terms. Trust me, once you understand shrimp sizing, you’ll never be confused at the seafood counter again!
The Quick Answer
Cocktail shrimp typically range from medium (41-50 per pound) to colossal (16-20 per pound), but the most popular size for shrimp cocktails is large to jumbo (31-40 or 21-30 per pound). These sizes are perfect for one-bite appetizers while still looking impressive on a platter.
Understanding Shrimp Size Labels
Let me break this down super easy for ya
Size Categories from Smallest to Largest:
- Small (71-90 shrimp per pound)
- Medium (41-60 per pound)
- Large (31-40 per pound)
- Jumbo (21-30 per pound)
- Colossal (16-20 per pound)
- Super Colossal (8-15 per pound)
Best Sizes for Different Uses
For Shrimp Cocktail Platters:
- Large to Jumbo (21-40 per pound) – These are your go-to sizes
- Why? They’re perfect for:
- One or two bites
- Easy handling with the tail
- Impressive presentation
- Not too expensive like the colossal ones
For Shrimp Salads:
- Small to Medium (41-90 per pound)
- Perfect because:
- Easier to eat in mixed dishes
- More economical
- Better distribution throughout the salad
How Much Should You Buy?
Here’s my rule of thumb for parties:
- Appetizers: Plan for 5-6 shrimp per person
- Main course: Plan for 8-10 shrimp per person
For example, if you’re having 10 guests for appetizers:
- You’ll need about 50-60 shrimp
- With jumbo shrimp (21-30 count), that’s about 2-2.5 pounds
Cooking Times for Different Sizes
Don’t overcook your shrimp! Here’s what I’ve learned works best
- Small (71-90): 1-2 minutes
- Medium (41-60): 2-3 minutes
- Large (31-40): 3-4 minutes
- Jumbo (21-30): 4-5 minutes
- Colossal (16-20): 5-7 minutes
Pro Tips from My Kitchen
-
Size Changes After Cooking Shrimp shrink when cooked! They’ll lose about 10-15% of their size,
-
Shell Impact: The size numbers are based on the form you buy them in. A 16-20 count with shells will give you less meat than the same count of peeled shrimp.
-
Storage Smarts:
- Fresh: Keep on ice in the fridge for 1-2 days
- Cooked: Good for 3-4 days refrigerated
- Frozen: Last up to 6 months
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Buying too small – They’ll shrink when cooked!
- Overcooking – Nobody likes rubbery shrimp
- Not considering your serving style
- Forgetting about tail-on vs. tail-off preferences
Budget Considerations
Let’s be real about prices:
- Larger shrimp cost more per pound
- But you need fewer pieces per serving
- Medium sizes often give the best value
- Pre-cooked usually costs more than raw
My Personal Recommendation
After years of serving shrimp cocktails, I always go with the 21-30 count (jumbo) size. They look impressive but won’t break the bank, and they’re just the right size for most people to enjoy in one or two bites.
FAQs About Cocktail Shrimp Sizes
Q: Can I mix different sizes?
A: Sure! But I wouldn’t recommend it for formal presentations.
Q: Should I buy fresh or frozen?
A: Unless you live on the coast, frozen is often fresher than “fresh”!
Q: Tail on or off?
A: For cocktail style, leave tails on – they make perfect handles!
Now go forth and serve some awesome shrimp cocktails!
