Corned beef is a salt-cured brisket that’s a staple in many Irish-American dishes around St. Patrick’s Day. But when shopping for corned beef, you’ll notice two main cuts: the flat cut (aka first cut or brisket cut) and the point cut (aka second cut or deckle). So what’s the difference, and which one should you choose for your recipe?
An Overview of Corned Beef Cuts
A beef brisket comes from the chest region of a cow It’s a large, tough cut that contains a lot of connective tissue When the whole brisket is cured with rock salt, spices, and sodium nitrite, it becomes corned beef.
To make it more manageable for cooking and serving, briskets are divided into two main sections:
-
Flat cut (first cut) – The leaner, rectangular bottom half of the brisket It has less fat marbling and is more uniform in thickness.
-
Point cut (second cut) – The fattier, irregularly-shaped upper half. It contains more fat marbling and connective tissue.
The differences between these two cuts impact the flavor, texture, and overall performance of the corned beef. Keep reading to learn how.
How They Compare: Flat Cut vs Point Cut
Appearance and Size
The flat cut is a large, rectangular cut that looks tidy and uniform. The point cut is smaller, thicker, and oddly shaped.
Winner: Flat cut for aesthetics and slicing
Fat Content and Flavor
The point cut contains heavy marbling and fat running through it, giving it a rich beefy flavor. The flat cut is leaner with a milder taste.
Winner: Point cut for fat and flavor
Tenderness and Texture
More fat and connective tissue makes the point cut more tender and juicy after cooking. The leaner flat cut can become dry if overcooked.
Winner: Point cut for tenderness
Price
The premium point cut costs more per pound than the flat cut.
Winner: Flat cut for budget-friendliness
How to Choose the Best Cut for Your Needs
Keep these comparisons in mind when deciding between flat cut and point cut:
-
For corned beef and cabbage, choose the flat cut. Its uniform shape looks prettier sliced, and the lean meat matches well with veggies.
-
For slow cooked dishes like corned beef in a crockpot or smoker, opt for the point cut. The fat keeps it tender and moist.
-
If you’re making Reuben sandwiches, the flat cut slices neatly. But the point cut has more flavor.
-
When buying corned beef on a budget, the flat cut gives you more meat for your money.
-
If you prefer fattier meats, go with the point cut for ultimate juiciness and beefy richness.
-
For an even mix of flavors and textures, buy both cuts and combine them in one recipe.
Cooking Methods for Flat Cut and Point Cut
Both cuts benefit from moist cooking methods since brisket meat can be tough. Here are some top cooking techniques:
-
Braising – Brown then simmer gently in liquid for 2-3 hours until fork tender.
-
Slow roasting – Cook low and slow in the oven, basting periodically.
-
Crockpot – Add seasonings and cook on low for 8-10 hours.
-
Smoking – Ideal for point cuts. Locks in moisture.
Whatever cut or cooking method you choose, let the meat rest before slicing to retain juices. Now that you know the differences between flat cut and point cut corned beef, you can make the perfect choice for your St. Paddy’s Day meal!
Key Takeaways: Choosing Flat Cut vs Point Cut Corned Beef
-
Flat cut – Lean, uniform rectangle. Budget-friendly. Good for sandwiches.
-
Point cut – Fatty, irregular shape. More flavorful. Ideal for slow, moist cooking.
-
For classic corned beef and cabbage, opt for the flat cut.
-
For pot roasts and crockpot dishes, choose the point cut.
-
Combining both cuts gives a balance of texture and taste.
-
Braise, slow roast, or smoke to keep these typically tough cuts tender.
Picking the right corned beef cut sets you up for St. Patrick’s Day success! Both have their merits, so base your decision on your recipe, cooking method, and personal preferences.
Corned Beef Brisket: A Salt-Cured Delight
Corned beef brisket, a quintessential ingredient in many St. Patrick’s Day meals, is celebrated for its rich, distinct flavor and tender texture. This salt-cured delight starts with a brisket, a cut from the animal’s lower chest or pectoral muscles, which bears a significant portion of the animal’s weight. Making corned beef involves curing the brisket with large grains of rock salt, also referred to as “corns” of salt, along with a blend of seasonings like mustard seeds, coriander seeds, and sometimes sugar. Adding sodium nitrite to the curing process helps prevent bacterial growth and gives corned beef its characteristic pink hue, enhancing its visual appeal and taste.
The art of selecting the best corned beef cut – whether a flat cut or point cut – plays a crucial role in crafting the perfect Patrick’s Day meal. Flat cuts are leaner and more uniform, making them ideal for slicing and recipes that call for a more refined presentation, such as corned beef hash or sandwiches. On the other hand, point cuts come with extra fat marbling and connective tissue, attributes that, when cooked on low heat, especially in a slow cooker, transform the meat into a fork-tender, flavorful delight. Whether served with cabbage, doused in a rich barbecue sauce, or simply seasoned with salt and spices, corned beef brisket is a hearty dish capable of anchoring any festive gathering with its savory, satisfying essence.
Best Corned Beef Cut: A Guide to the Perfect Selection
Selecting the best corned beef cut is a pivotal decision that sets the stage for a memorable culinary experience, particularly when preparing for an occasion as cherished as St. Patrick’s Day. This guide aims to navigate the intricacies of corned beef, from the salt-cured brisket that forms its foundation to the nuanced differences between the various cuts available. Understanding these distinctions is key to mastering the art of cooking corned beef, ensuring that each bite is as flavorful and tender as tradition demands. Whether you’re a seasoned chef or a home cook looking to impress, this exploration into the best corned beef cuts will equip you with the knowledge to choose wisely and cook confidently.
The Difference Between Flat Cut And Point Cut Corned Beef
FAQ
Is point or flat corned beef better?
Out of five adults the winner was the point cut! It turns out that the point cut has more fat which makes it more flavorful and juicy. Both cuts of meat were tasty, but the point cut was the clear winner in our home.
What is better, the point or the flat?
If you’re someone who prefers slices of brisket, then the flat is the way to go. Due to the shape and the lean texture, the flat makes it very easy to cut uniform slices. On top of that, the meat isn’t too fatty and tastes delicious. Now, if you like shredded meat for sandwiches or BBQ, the point is for you.
Does point cut corned beef shred?
When you go to the market to collect your corned beef brisket, you may come across a point cut and flat cut. Point is fattier, more tender and will shred a bit, making it ideal for hash. Whereas flat is more lean and will slice into nice, thick strips.
What is the best cut of corned beef for boiled dinner?
However, in the case of corned beef, plan for 3/4 pound, since it tends to cook down a lot. If buying regular fresh brisket, look for the point cut, which comes with a bit of fat, making it more flavorful. If all you can find is the flat (leaner) cut, it’ll also work just fine.