Beef stroganoff is the ultimate comfort food. With its rich, savory sauce coating tender pieces of beef, this classic Russian dish has been winning over taste buds around the world for generations. But for those unfamiliar with stroganoff, the question remains – what does it actually taste like?
As a lover of beef stroganoff, I’m here to walk you through all the complex flavors that come together to create this irresistible dish. Read on for a complete guide to the taste of beef stroganoff.
The Key Flavors in Beef Stroganoff
Beef stroganoff features a perfect balance of flavors that mingle and complement each other. Here are some of the main taste elements
-
Beef – The most pronounced flavor is the savoriness of the beef itself. Strips of tender, juicy beef are cooked quickly to medium-rare doneness so they stay moist and tender. The beef provides a rich, meaty base.
-
Onions – Sautéed onions add layers of sweetness and depth of flavor Their softened texture also enhances the heartiness of the dish.
-
Mushrooms – Earthy, nutty mushrooms like cremini or white button lend an umami richness when browned in the cooking process.
-
Broth – Beef or chicken broth contributes body and savoriness to the sauce. Some recipes also use wine or brandy.
-
Sour cream – Cooling sour cream provides a pleasant tanginess and creaminess that cuts through the richness. Greek yogurt is sometimes used instead.
-
Warm spices – Paprika, nutmeg, bay leaf and other spices add subtle depth.
The Sauce Makes All the Difference
The creamy sauce is truly what ties everything together and makes beef stroganoff so special. A mixture of broth, mustard, and sour cream comes together to create a luscious texture with a balanced, nuanced flavor. The sauce clings to the beef, enveloping it in savory richness with just a hint of bright tang. This is what elevates beef stroganoff beyond just another beef and noodles dinner.
Depending on variations in the recipe, the sauce may be infused with tomatoes, wine, extra mustard, or other ingredients to put a spin on the flavor. But the creamy broth-and-sour cream base is the essential starting point. When properly prepared, the sauce should have a velvety consistency that gracefully coats each morsel.
Texture Contrasts Add Interest
In addition to great flavor, beef stroganoff features an array of textures to make eating it a multidimensional experience:
-
Tender beef – The meat retains a melt-in-your-mouth tenderness when cooked properly. This contrasts with the creaminess of the sauce.
-
Toothsome noodles – Hearty egg noodles or spirals withstand the rich sauce and provide substance.
-
Crunchy onions – Onions lend a pleasant crunch.
-
Meaty mushrooms – Mushrooms strike a balance between juicy and meaty.
-
Cool, creamy dollops – Sour cream served on top or on the side provides a cooling, tangy contrast.
This variety of textures comes together to create a highly craveable dish. Each bite offers something different.
It’s All About Balance
Like all great comfort foods, beef stroganoff is perfectly balanced. No single flavor overpowers the others. Instead, you get waves of flavor – beefiness, onions, mushrooms, spice, creaminess – that mingle and complement each other.
The recipe brings sweetness, savory umami, tang, spice, salinity, and richness into harmony. At its best, every component builds on the others to form a cohesive and irresistible flavor profile. It’s wonderfully well-rounded.
Warm and Satisfying
Above all, beef stroganoff tastes warm, satisfying, and soulful. The steaming hot dish on a chilly evening immediately invokes feelings of comfort. As the scent of beef, onions, and paprika fills the kitchen, you know you’re in for a treat.
Settling in with a hearty plate of beef stroganoff promises a deeply nourishing, stick-to-your ribs kind of meal that will leave you feeling warm, cozy, and sated. That’s the magic of this classic recipe.
Cooking Tips for Best Flavor
To get the most flavor out of your beef stroganoff, follow these helpful tips:
-
Use sirloin or tenderloin for the most tender, beefy taste.
-
Cook the beef over very high heat to get a good sear.
-
Sauté the mushrooms and onions thoroughly until browned.
-
Use real sour cream or Greek yogurt, not low-fat versions.
-
Simmer the finished sauce gently so the flavors can meld.
-
Season assertively with salt, pepper, and herbs.
When prepared with care using quality ingredients, beef stroganoff delivers on its promise of being a richly delicious meal. The time and effort pays off in flavor.
Recipe Variations to Try
Once you master the classic, try these tasty beef stroganoff variations:
-
Mushroom stroganoff – Use all mushrooms instead of beef for a vegetarian version.
-
Chicken stroganoff – Substitute chicken for a lighter take.
-
Turkey or lamb stroganoff
-
Smoked paprika stroganoff – For a smoky twist.
-
Parsley pesto stroganoff – Stir some bright Italian parsley pesto into the sauce.
-
Dijon stroganoff – Amp up the mustard for zing.
-
Bacon stroganoff – Crispy bits of bacon in the sauce add a salty crunch.
Let your creativity run wild! The possibilities for customizing beef stroganoff are endless.
An International Favorite
While beef stroganoff originated in Russia in the 19th century, this magnificent dish has gained worldwide popularity over the years. With a few localized tweaks, stroganoff can be found from America to Europe to Asia. Wherever you may taste it, you’ll discover the same craveable experience of rich, tender beef blanketed in luscious creamy sauce. For me, a steaming plate of beef stroganoff spells comfort no matter where I am. I hope you’ll take the opportunity to try this sensational recipe. Your belly and your taste buds will thank you.
The Best Meat for Stroganoff and How to Cut It
To begin testing, I started with a very basic working recipe that I pulled together after examining over a dozen popular recipes online and in books. I started by sautéing beef in a skillet, removing it, then adding sliced mushrooms and onions and cooking them until browned. Then I added a splash of wine to deglaze, along with some chicken stock, allowing the mixture to cook down. I finished it off by returning the meat to the pan, seasoning with salt and pepper, and whisking some sour cream and fresh parsley into the mix before dumping it all over a big bowl of buttered egg noodles.
Not bad, but it definitely smacked of high school cafeteria. We can do better.
Traditionally, tenderloin is the meat of choice for Stroganoff, and after testing out a few alternatives—strip steak and ribeye along with more inexpensive cuts like flap meat, hanger, flank, and skirt—I decided to stick with tradition (flap meat and hanger came in a close second). Its by far the tenderest cut of meat around, and though its lacking in flavor, I figured I could compensate with a more flavorful sauce.
Next question: what shape should I cut the meat?
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__seriouseats.com__s__2014__12__20150110-beef-stroganoff-food-lab-03-e44ff54ab07045d4aea2d36290bab959.jpg)
The most popular way is to cut the meat into strips, but this leads to a big problem: with so much surface area, strips of steak end up exuding a lot of moisture into the pan as they cook. This moisture drastically reduces the efficiency of cooking (It takes about 500 times as much energy to get one gram of water to evaporate as it does to raise the temperature of that water by one degree Farenheit!). Unless youve got a jet engine installed in your kitchen, its nearly impossible to get a good, deep brown sear on a thin strip of beef without completely overcooking it. Tenderloin also happens to be one of the worst meats around when overcooked—with virtually no fat to lubricate it, it gets very mealy and dry. Cubes of tenderloin fared a little better, but they still ran into the same problem.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__seriouseats.com__s__2014__12__20150110-beef-stroganoff-food-lab-02-3973d359f27d4473b52abfecf02d294d.jpg)
I wondered if adding some sort of marinade or rub that improves browning qualities would help things out. I tried a rub with a bit of sugar, as well as a marinade that used some soy sauce, and a simple dredge in flour (another common technique in recipes). They all helped a little, but none of them was a silver bullet against overcooking.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__seriouseats.com__s__2014__12__20150110-beef-stroganoff-food-lab-04-7fca776085c645fc83954f0eff50cfff.jpg)
Then I thought: Whats the point of cutting the meat before cooking it? Couldnt we get better results by simply cooking the meat whole as tenderloin steaks, then slice it for serving?
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__seriouseats.com__s__2014__12__20150110-beef-stroganoff-food-lab-01-8bebfd12f11a4b4e8869e20d9d350d47.jpg)
I brought home some thick tenderloin steaks, dried them carefully with paper towels (excess moisture can reduce pan temperature), then seasoned them up with a blend of salt, pepper, and some paprika (a common ingredient in many recipes that also improves browning), pressing the mixture firmly onto the steaks to make sure it fully adhered.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__seriouseats.com__s__2014__12__20150110-beef-stroganoff-food-lab-06-6f9c3b28b77546c2870c4baf4c9b5654.jpg)
I then heated up some oil in a skillet over high heat until just barely smoking and added the steaks, flipping them occasionally until their centers hit a nice rare to medium-rare (flipping a steak multiple times as it cooks can actually improve how evenly it cooks internally). Typically, I prefer my steaks more towards the medium side, as this allows internal fat to soften, making the steak juicier and more tender, but with lean tenderloin, rarer is the way to go.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__seriouseats.com__s__2014__12__20150110-beef-stroganoff-food-lab-14-41b02b7cdd1f491e88ccff40141d3672.jpg)
As soon as theyd developed a dark brown crust and came up to around 115°F (46°C) in the center (theyd continue to rise about another five degrees off-heat as they rested), I pulled the steaks out of the pan and set them aside while I finished up the remainder of the sauce. Finally, I placed the steaks back into the pan along with their drippings to rewarm, slicing them and fanning them out just before serving.
Did the final dish look exactly like the Stroganoff in my mind? Nope. But it tasted a damn sight better than any beef Stroganoff Ive had in the past. In my book, thats a win.
Now it was time to tackle the next element: the mushrooms and onions.
Building the Perfect Sauce
With the meat and vegetables out of the way, it was finally time to start tweaking the sauce. Stock and sour cream were a given, but what about the other additions? I ended up going for a sort of more-is-more approach, letting ingredients build on each other, starting with white wine.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__seriouseats.com__s__2014__12__20150110-beef-stroganoff-food-lab-23-36966797b4ea437991d1eb9fb17909db.jpg)
The acidity of white wine is essential here. It brings brightness to an otherwise heavy dish. Fully reducing it before adding other liquids is vital for good flavor. I also added a dab of mustard along with all of the collected juices left on the plate as my steaks rested. No point in wasting that good flavor.
Long-time Food Lab readers know whats coming next: the umami bombs.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__seriouseats.com__s__2014__12__20150110-beef-stroganoff-food-lab-20-e87ab766aec44a03a10086e070748b00.jpg)
Ingredients high in glutamic acid can make meaty dishes taste meatier, and there are a few sauces that are packed full of them. Typically Id use fish sauce, soy sauce, and marmite (or a combination thereof), but as Worcestershire sauce (another umami powerhouse) is so common in Stroganoff recipes, I decided to add a splash of it here in place of the marmite.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__seriouseats.com__s__2014__12__20150110-beef-stroganoff-food-lab-19-282a864109e741f19fa835948c080d8d.jpg)
After adding in my sauce ingredients, I finished off the dish by adding some homemade or store-bought low-sodium chicken stock and a good amount of sour cream before letting it reduce into a rich sauce on the stovetop.
Uh oh. Not a good idea. Sour cream is inherently unstable and tends to break and turn into a nasty, curdled mess when brought to a boil. I tried fully reducing my sauce before adding the sour cream. This works, but the sauce loses a lot of its noodle- and meat-coating richness. I considered turning to thickening my sauce with crème fraîche, a similarly acidic dairy product that doesnt curdle, but it didnt have quite the same thick richness as sour cream.
So whats the problem here?
The issue is that for a sauce that contains both water and fat—like the sauce in a Stroganoff—to remain smooth and rich, it has to be fully emulsified. That is, the fat molecules have to be dispersed in drops that are so tiny that they have a hard time coming back together and separating into distinct, curdled clumps. There are a few ways you can help ingredients emulsify. One is through mechanical stimulation. I could potentially strain my sauce out, pour it into a blender, blend it on high speed until smooth, then add it back to the pot, but that seems ludicrous for such a simple dish.
The other method? By introducing some sort of physical particle that will prevent fat molecules from coming into close contact with each other while simultaneously increasing the viscosity of the liquid enough that the chances of molecules flowing around and bumping into each other are minimized.
Its for this reason that many recipes have you dredge your beef in flour or add flour to the mushrooms as they cook down. Flour releases starch granules which in turn both thicken a sauce and run interference, preventing fat from coalescing.
Personally, I dont much like the stodgy nature of a flour-thickened sauce for cases like this. Instead, I turned to an animal-based source: Gelatin. Powdered gelatin can act as a stabilizer in much the same way that flour can, and it does it in a way that doesnt lead to gloppy or stodgy sauce. Unfortunately, I found that I needed way more gelatin (about a quarter cup!) than I really wanted to make a bulletproof, unbreakable sauce. As soon as I dumped the cold sour cream into the hot skillet, it would break.
The solution? Treat the sour cream exactly the same way Id treat an egg in a custard: by tempering it. By slowly whisking the hot liquid into the sour cream in a separate bowl, I was able to raise its temperature more gently, to the point that when it was finally hot, it was diluted enough by the gelatin-rich sauce that it never got a chance to break.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__seriouseats.com__s__2014__12__20150110-beef-stroganoff-food-lab-25-1132eb87bdeb435cb4bc0361546a6fcd.jpg)
Once the stock is fully incorporated into the sour cream, its a simple matter of pouring it back into the skillet and adding back the meat for some gentle reheating.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/__opt__aboutcom__coeus__resources__content_migration__serious_eats__seriouseats.com__s__2014__12__20150110-beef-stroganoff-food-lab-27-b75c2cbaa92a4f2d922feda9380a188e.jpg)
Though Stroganoff is often served spooned over buttered noodles, I took a more Italian approach here by removing the heated meat to a cutting board, then adding the noodles directly to the sauce along with a bit of their cooking water, heating the noodles, sauce, onions, and mushrooms together until the sauce fully coated each piece of pasta with flavor.
After that I plated it (warm bowls, please!), sliced the meat, fanned it out on top, and spooned over a bit more of the leftover sauce. A big dollop of sour cream on the side and a sprinkle of parsley finish it off.
What you wind up with is a dish thats at once recognizable—one taste of this and your heart will be singing Stroooooganooooooofffff!—yet tastier than its inspiration in almost every way I can think of. Tender, juicy, medium-rare meat in a rich, deeply browned sauce with chunks of (properly cooked!) mushrooms and onions on top of pasta that has soaked up every last ounce of extra flavor.
Now if that doesnt sound comforting to you, then I give up. Ill be over in the corner eating my dinner.
The Original Beef Stroganoff of Imperial Russia
FAQ
How would you describe beef stroganoff?
Beef Stroganoff is basically tender strips of beef and mushrooms, cooked in a creamy sauce and rounded off with sour cream. You may want to make this with a tender cut of beef, such as tenderloin or top sirloin. Traditionally served over egg noodles, it also tastes delicious on rice or spaetzle.”
Why is beef stroganoff so good?
Quartered mushrooms and a combination of pearl onions and shallots give the finished dish a more interesting texture and flavor. Adding gelatin to the chicken stock gives it more body, letting the sauce come together more tightly to coat the meat and noodles.
What flavor is stroganoff?
-
The Kitchnhttps://www.thekitchn.comBeef Stroganoff Recipe (So Tender) | The KitchnThe sliced beef is so tender, the mushrooms and onions are perfectly caramelized, and the sour cream adds just the right amount of richness and tang. … Beef s…
-
Allrecipeshttps://www.allrecipes.comEasy Stroganoff Recipe – AllrecipesReviews (127) … This is one of my husband’s favorite recipes! I changed almost everything in it, but I followed the basic outline. I substituted ground turkey…
-
Good Foodhttps://www.bbcgoodfood.comBeef stroganoff recipe | Good FoodClassic stroganoff sauce is made with onion, garlic, crème fraîche or soured cream, mustard and beef stock, which creates the distinctive rich, tangy gravy. Pap…
What do you eat beef stroganoff with?