What Cut of Meat is Beef Wellington? A Deep Dive into this Lavish Dish
Beef Wellington is the ultimate celebratory dish, a tender filet of beef wrapped in mushroom duxelle, prosciutto and encased in flaky puff pastry. When perfectly executed, slicing into a beef Wellington reveals deliciously pink, tender beef nestled in a crispy, golden crust. However, achieving beef Wellington perfection hinges greatly on using the right cut of beef.
So what is the ideal cut of meat that transforms beef Wellington from intimidating challenge into resplendent success? Let’s examine the factors that determine the best cuts to use when making this opulent classic
Choosing a Tender Cut is Critical
Tenderness ranks as the most important quality for beef Wellington. During baking, the meat cooks to medium rare doneness inside the pastry shell. Cuts that start out tender remain succulent, while tougher cuts turn chewy and dry.
For optimal tenderness, cuts from the loin or rib sections work best. Here are top options:
Filet Mignon/Beef Tenderloin – The gold standard. Extremely tender with mild flavor that allows other Wellington flavors to shine.
Striploin/New York Strip – Also tender though not as buttery as tenderloin. Remove any gristle before wrapping in pastry.
Top Sirloin – Lean yet tender, though cook slightly less to prevent toughening.
Tri-Tip – Good marbling provides tenderness, though odd shape can make wrapping challenging.
Any of these tender cuts deliver melt-in-your-mouth beef delicately encased in that crisp, flaky pastry shell.
Avoid Less Tender Cuts
On the other hand, cuts from the chuck, round, brisket or flank are too tough and chewy for beef Wellington. Here are cuts to avoid:
Chuck or Round – Fibrous and chewy when baked in puff pastry.
Brisket or Shank – Connective tissue needs long cooking beef Wellington doesn’t provide.
Flank or Skirt – Toughen and dry out during baking process.
Ground Beef – Wrong texture and too high fat content.
Using a tender cut is crucial for beef Wellington success. Tough cuts make for a disappointing meal after all that preparation.
Tenderloin Reigns Supreme for Flavor and Tenderness
For the ultimate beef Wellington experience, tenderloin is the prime cut of choice. Here’s why tenderloin can’t be beat:
-
Extreme tenderness – With minimal connective tissue, tenderloin stays tender when cooked. Other cuts risk toughening.
-
Mild flavor – Allows the other components to shine rather than overpowering.
-
Uniform shape – Tapers elegantly when wrapped in puff pastry.
-
Lean yet moist – Has enough marbling to stay juicy without excess fat.
-
Upscale – As a premium cut, suits the lavish nature of beef Wellington.
No other cut matches the sublime tenderness and flavor balance of tenderloin. For the best chance of beef Wellington success, tenderloin is the foolproof option.
Tips for Using Tenderloin
When using tenderloin, keep these guidelines in mind:
-
Purchase center-cut or trim/tie a whole tenderloin for uniform thickness.
-
Shoot for 2-2.5 inch thick pieces to prevent overcooking.
-
Generously season the meat before wrapping in duxelles and pastry.
-
Cook to no more than medium rare, removing at 135°F internal temperature.
-
Let rest at least 10 minutes for even pinkness when sliced.
-
Cut perfect slices across the grain with a sharp knife.
Following these steps delivers perfect, rosy medium rare tenderloin nestled inside crisp, golden pastry.
Alternatives When Tenderloin is Unavailable
Tenderloin delivers optimum results, but budget or availability may dictate using other cuts. Here are some alternatives:
-
Filet Mignon – Essentially the same as tenderloin, though cut into steaks. Use multiple filets in place of a whole tenderloin.
-
Striploin (New York Strip) – Next most tender after tenderloin. Remove any gristle before wrapping.
-
Top Sirloin – Lean and fairly tender, though not as buttery as tenderloin. Cook less for best results.
-
Tri-Tip – Good marbling and tenderness, though odd shape makes wrapping difficult.
While not ideal substitutes, these cuts can make tasty beef Wellington in a pinch. Just take care not to overcook them.
The Perfect Cut Transforms Beef Wellington
The right cut of beef takes beef Wellington from intimidating challenge to triumphant success. Treat guests to tender slices of perfectly cooked, tenderloin nestled in crisp, flaky pastry. When made properly, it’s beef Wellington at its spectacular best.
The Prosciutto Layer of Beef Wellington
Prosciutto (or Parma ham) comes in two forms. Prosciutto crudo (a raw cured ham) and prosciutto cotto which is a cooked ham. I will use prosciutto crudo for an additional layer in our Beef Wellington recipe.
Prosciutto (I will refer to prosciutto crudo as just prosciutto for the remainder of this article) is made from high quality pork legs. The legs are salted for a period of time then washed and hung to dry at a certain temperature for an even longer time period. The resulting meat is safe to eat raw because of the curing process. Depending where prosciutto is made, the length of time it is hung, and what it is seasoned with will all contribute to different flavor profiles.
When using prosciutto for this recipe, you can either order it sliced thin from your butcher or buy it pre-packaged. For this Beef Wellington recipe, you will lay down overlapping pieces of prosciutto to form a prosciutto blanket for the duxelles and meat. Since prosciutto doesn’t have a very high moisture content itself, it makes another barrier to protect our puff pastry from moisture.
TIPS:
Overlap the prosciutto to make a solid sheet of meat. Any holes will allow moisture to escape
Chill the prosciutto prior to trying to remove from the packaging. If it gets warm it will tear easily
Take your time when handling prosciutto. If it does tear, push it back into place to cover the hole
Essential Supplies To Make Beef Wellington
To find supplies for making a perfect Beef Wellington, visit my Amazon storefront for my recommendations.
Beef Wellington: Learn about the cut of this meat! SALTOPIA
FAQ
What cut of beef is best for beef wellington?
A center-cut beef tenderloin is the best cut for beef Wellington. This tender, boneless cut has very little gristle or fat and is fairly uniform in shape. When you’re shopping, look for a tenderloin that has an even thickness, which will help it cook more evenly.
What kind of meat is in a Wellington?
It is a beef filet enveloped together with duxelles in puff pastry, baked, and served with a truffle or Madeira sauce.
Why is beef wellington so hard to make?
I’m guessing you’re looking at the entire tenderloin where wellington is usually made with just the center cut from it. This is because a whole tenderloin is quite asymmetric which makes it hard to cook evenly. By the time the fat end is medium rare, the tip (filet mignon) is grossly overcooked.
What joint of beef for beef wellington?
Fillet of Beef Joint – Beef Wellington.
What kind of meat is used in Beef Wellington?
The meat used in beef Wellington, which is typically a fillet steak, beef tenderloin, or filet mignon, is a nice cut. It makes use of the center-cut, which is thought to be the most tender and juicy part of the cow. The meat is encased in a mustard sauce, followed by prosciutto and mushroom duxelles.
What is the best cut of beef for Beef Wellington?
The ideal cut of beef for beef wellington is a center cut piece of beef tenderloin. Beef tenderloin is the most tender cut of beef and comes from the short loin primal cut. It has very little fat marbled throughout, which results in a tender, lean, and flavorful piece of meat when cooked.
Does Beef Wellington taste good after baking?
With its melt-in-your-mouth meat crisp crust, and presentation flair, beef wellington always impresses. However, achieving the ideal texture and flavor requires using the right cut of beef. When considering beef wellington, you want a cut that remains tender and juicy even after baking.
How did Beef Wellington get its name?
Beef Wellington got its name from Arthur Wellesley, the 1st Duke of Wellington, who reportedly counted the dish among his favorite recipes. Whether this is true or not, Beef Wellington has become an iconic example of English cuisine, following a long tradition of meats baked in pastry dough.
Is beef tenderloin a good choice for Beef Wellington?
There are a few key benefits that make beef tenderloin the best choice for beef wellington: Tenderness – The tenderloin is the most naturally tender cut of beef. The muscle gets very little use, so it has thin connective tissue and fine marbling. This allows it to cook up incredibly tender.
Can a tenderloin be trimmed to make a Wellington?
Yes, a whole tenderloin roast can be trimmed and tied to create an evenly shaped cut for beef wellington. Is beef wellington better with pork or prosciutto?