The difference between Maine lobster vs. Canadian lobster is truly a tale of two gulfs. It is one of nuance defined not by a border, an arbitrary boundary, but by geography. Though they are one and the same, there are differences between lobster caught along the Maine coast and those trapped further north in Canada—differences in volume and price, but also taste and texture.
The Homarus americanus, the American lobster, is considered the best tasting. Native to the northwestern Atlantic, their greatest concentration extends from the Gulf of Maine northeast to the Bay of Fundy, around the Nova Scotia peninsula, and west into the southern Gulf of St. Lawrence. These “true” cold water lobsters are not simply a meal; they are a preferred dining experience in the finest restaurants and kitchens around the globe.
As much as demand sets price differences, so does volume. The price of Canadian lobster is usually lower than that of Maine lobster, primarily due to volume. More than 60% of lobster landings in North America occur in Canadian waters, accounting for more than half of the world’s lobster supply. The price points of lobster in Maine are seasonal. Prices are lower in the fall when lobster landings are at their highest as demand begins to ebb after Labor Day. Conversely, when lobsters migrate far offshore during winter, landings decrease because there is less fishing. From January to March, Prices are at their highest, peaking in early spring before the warmer returns, and prices are lowered again.
Lobster lovers have long debated which region produces the tastiest crustaceans Maine or Canada. With their cold pristine waters and generations of fishing heritage both places yield exceptional seafood. But when it comes to the king of shellfish, does one surpass the other in flavor and quality?
As a seafood blogger with a passion for lobster, I set out to uncover the truth. After extensive research and taste tests, I believe the answer is clear: Maine lobster is better than Canadian. Here’s why.
Flavor Profile
The icy Maine waters lend sweetness to the lobsters’ meat that Canadian lobsters can’t quite match. The cooler temperatures also firm up the texture pleasantly. Upon my first bite of a fresh Maine lobster tail, I was struck by the succulent tenderness balanced with a subtle brininess. The sweeter profile really comes through when the meat is dressed simply, say, with drawn butter or a squeeze of lemon.
Canadian lobster tastes pleasant too, don’t get me wrong. It’s just not quite as sweet, especially when compared side-by-side with the Maine variety. I detected a slightly higher saltiness in the Canadian meat in my tastings. For some palates, this extra salinity reads as more robust flavor. For me, Maine has the edge.
Meat Quality
Within their hard shells, Maine and Canadian lobsters contain similar claw, tail, and body meat. However, differences emerge in texture and tenderness.
Maine lobster meat is tender with a satisfying firmness. When cooked correctly, the chunks hold together well for dipping and come away in perfect bites. The cold waters lend a pleasant firmness while still allowing the meat to achieve tender perfection.
The Canadian lobster meat I tried had a noticeably softer texture in comparison. While buttery softness appeals to some, I found the Canadian meat almost too delicate at times. Pieces fell apart easier when handled. For peak lobster roll construction or simply grasping claw meat, Maine has the upper hand in meat integrity.
Size Availability
Canadian fisheries have less restrictive size regulations compared to Maine. This translates into more large lobster availability in Canada. For those who prize jumbo lobsters for their impressive presentation, abundance of meat, and value, Canada is the place to turn.
Maine lobsters max out at about 2 pounds on average, based on current laws. Their smaller average size means less meat per lobster. However, fans argue Maine lobsters make up for it with their sweeter taste in a petite, tender package. For impressively giant lobsters, Canada takes the crown. But Maine still prevails in flavor.
Sustainability
Both Maine and Canada prioritize responsible harvesting regulations to preserve lobster populations. Limited season lengths, enforced size minimums, protection of egg-bearing females, and other rules foster sustainability.
Some small differences emerge, however. Canada faces challenges like overfishing, while Maine collaborates closely with the industry to devise updated best practices. Both make important contributions through research and monitoring too.
It’s difficult to declare one country the clear winner in sustainability efforts. The bottom line is both remain committed to ethical harvesting for a healthy future fishery.
Price and Value
Canadian lobster prices are generally 25-50% lower than the Maine variety. The increased availability of larger lobsters keeps Canadian pricing down. The fame of Maine lobster as a luxury item also boosts its cost.
When you factor in the sweeter taste and tender texture of Maine lobster, though, it becomes clear you get what you pay for. The value stems from superb flavor and meat quality. For a special treat, springing for Maine lobster makes sense. Canadian lobster offers savings, but Maine takes the category of overall value.
Culinary Uses
Chefs leverage the unique traits of Maine and Canadian lobsters to suit different cuisine styles. The tender, sweet Maine lobster shines in light preparations like lobster rolls, baked lobster tails, clambakes, and lobster mac and cheese where its flavor profile stands out.
The heartier Canadian lobster is ideal for dishes like lobster Newburg, lobster thermidor, and lobster bisque that complement its firmness. Canadian lobster also lends itself well to grilling, broiling, and sautéing. The regional differences can guide your recipe selections.
Consumer Popularity
Public perception and repute play a role in perceptions about Maine and Canadian lobster. Thanks to Maine’s history as an iconic lobster fishing destination, its global reputation tingles tastebuds. The Maine lobster fishery also drives local tourism.
Canadian lobster has its adherents too, especially those seeking value, size, and widespread availability. However, polls and expert opinions indicate a majority of consumers consider Maine lobster superior and more desirable overall.
Verdict: Maine Reigns Supreme
After diving into all factors from flavor to sustainability and beyond, I give the crown to Maine lobster as the overall winner. The sweeter profile, tender meat texture, strict fishing regulations, and artisanal fishing culture clinch Maine’s status as lobster royalty.
Canadian lobster offers affordable abundance and jumbo sizes, which appeal to many shoppers. Its firmer meat also suits certain recipes beautifully. However, for peak lobster taste and experience, Maine comes out on top. Their pristine habitat lends unmatched flavor that tasting panels and lobster connoisseurs praise.
Fun Facts about Maine and Canadian Lobsters
- They thrive in cold, shallow water preferring a depth of anywhere between 13 and 164 feet. However, they can at times be found in depths up to 1500 feet. They prefer these shallow areas because they like to have a lot of rocks around so they can hide from predators.
- This lobster species is known and prized for its sweet flavor, tender meat, gian claws, and hard shells.
- Lobster was once considered a “poor mans food” before becoming the luxury gourmet item we know it as today.
Maine Lobsters vs. Canadian Lobsters
At Maine Lobster Now, we offer both Maine and Canadian lobsters. Our jumbo lobsters come from Canada due to differences in fishing regulations between Canada and the United States. The main difference worth noting however is that the slightly warmer, yet still cold, waters of Maine provide the most ideal lobster meat. Maine lobster meat is sweet and tender, while the Canadian lobster comes in larger sizes.
The true difference to keep an eye on when comparing lobsters is cold water vs. warm water lobsters. Or rather, Maine and Canadian (cold water) lobsters compared to California and Australian lobsters (warm water).
America vs. Canada…who has the BEST lobster?
FAQ
Does Maine have the best lobster?
-
Taste and Texture:The cold, clean waters of Maine provide an ideal environment for lobsters, resulting in sweet, succulent, and tender meat.
-
Sustainable Practices:Maine’s lobster fishery is known for its commitment to sustainable practices, contributing to the high quality and ethical harvesting of lobsters.
-
Availability:Maine lobstermen harvest over 80% of the lobster consumed in North America, making it widely available and readily accessible in many markets.
-
Claws and Meat:Maine lobsters have claws, which are known for their sweet, tender meat, and they also offer more edible meat overall, according to Overnight Lobster and Calabash Cove.
Why are Maine lobsters better?
The Maine lobster is different from other types of lobster because they are bigger, with much larger claws, and they grow at a slower rate (this makes the …
What is the best type of lobster to buy?
In contrast, warm-water lobsters, typically caught in the Caribbean, have softer, less flavorful meat. For the best quality, always opt for cold-water lobsters, such as Live Lobsters from Maine or Cold Water Lobster Tails, for superior taste and texture.
Is European lobster better than American?
As opposed to Maine lobster, the taste of the European lobster is more flavorful, with a stronger sea flavor. This is because it is fished in more shallow areas, in between rocks and corrals. If you really love seafood, your palate may appreciate the blue lobster more.
Are Maine lobsters better than Canadian lobsters?
In addition, Maine lobsters can survive up to 48 hours after getting out of the water. This is an advantage in helping Maine lobsters be transported better, and they retain their freshness and flavor. Canadian lobsters live in cold waters, so their shells are thicker and stiffer than Maine lobsters.
Do Canadian lobsters live in colder waters than Maine lobsters?
That Canadian lobsters live in colder waters than Maine lobsters is a given. The seawater temperature that lobsters thrive in the Gulf of Maine is higher than the temperatures of the Gulf of St. Lawrence waters.
Why do Canadian lobsters have thicker shells than Maine lobsters?
It’s not that Canadian lobsters have thicker shells than Maine lobsters because of colder waters; such a difference in thickness would be negligible. Canadian lobster shells are likely to harden earlier due to the water turning colder sooner there than in Maine.
Why are lobster prices so low in Maine?
More than 60% of lobster landings in North America occur in Canadian waters, accounting for more than half of the world’s lobster supply. The price points of lobster in Maine are seasonal. Prices are lower in the fall when lobster landings are at their highest as demand begins to ebb after Labor Day.
Do Canadian lobsters live longer on land?
Canadian lobsters can live longer on land. The major differences between Canadian and Maine lobsters are appearance, habitat, range, prey, and relationships with humans. When comparing the Canadian and Maine lobsters, it is easy to see the traits they share and the ones they don’t.
Why is Maine lobster so important?
Maine lobster is a crucial part of Maine’s economy and culture, making it an important part of America’s economy and culture, much more than Canadian lobster is to Canada. Professional chefs look to Maine lobsters for their most prized dishes that people flock to their restaurants to enjoy.