Are you tired of wondering where to find high-quality organic chicken that’s both healthy and humanely raised? I’ve been there too! After years of searching for the perfect organic chicken source, I’ve put together this ultimate guide to help you navigate the sometimes confusing world of organic poultry.
Why Choose Organic Chicken in the First Place?
Before we dive into where to buy it, let’s quickly cover why organic chicken is worth the extra effort and cost:
- Better for your health: Organic chickens contain more omega-3 fatty acids and nutrients while avoiding antibiotics that contribute to antibiotic-resistant bacteria
- Better for the animals: These chickens enjoy more humane living conditions with access to the outdoors
- Better for the environment: Organic farming practices promote biodiversity and soil health without synthetic pesticides
- Peace of mind: Third-party certifiers audit organic producers annually to verify compliance with USDA organic regulations
As one chicken farmer told me “The difference between conventional and organic chicken isn’t just in the taste—it’s in knowing that your food choices align with your values.”
What Makes Chicken Truly Organic?
To earn that USDA organic label chicken must meet strict standards
- Fed 100% organic feed (no animal byproducts)
- No antibiotics or artificial hormones
- Access to outdoors and space to roam
- Humane treatment from birth to processing
But here’s the thing—not all organic labels are created equal! The “organic” label really just confirms the chickens were fed certified organic diet. It doesn’t always guarantee the best farming practices or quality of life. For truly ethical chicken, look for additional certifications like “pasture-raised” or “Animal Welfare Approved.”
Top 8 Places to Buy Organic Chicken
Now for the main event—where can you actually find good organic chicken? I’ve ranked these options based on quality, convenience, and availability:
1. Local Farms and Farmers Markets
Nothing beats buying directly from the source! Local organic farms often provide the freshest chicken with complete transparency about raising practices.
How to find them:
- Use directories like LocalHarvest.org or EatWild to find farms in your area
- Visit weekend farmers markets and talk directly with farmers
- Join a CSA (Community Supported Agriculture) program for regular deliveries
Pro tip: Don’t be shy about asking farmers questions like: “Are your chickens truly cage-free on pasture?” or “What type of feed do you use?” A good farmer will be happy to share their practices.
2. Natural Grocery Stores and Co-ops
Health food stores typically have excellent selections of organic chicken from trusted brands.
Best options include:
- Whole Foods Market
- Sprouts Farmers Market
- Local food co-ops
These stores carry whole organic chickens as well as parts like breasts, thighs, and wings. Prices are moderate compared to conventional supermarkets but cheaper than delivery services.
3. Online Retailers and Farm Direct Websites
The internet has made it easier than ever to get organic chicken delivered right to your door!
Top online sources:
- D’Artagnan: Offers USDA-certified free-range organic chicken that’s air-chilled for better flavor
- Joyce Farms: Pasture-raised, non-GMO chicken shipped nationwide
- Crowd Cow: Despite the name, they have one of the best selections of free-range and organic chicken online
- ButcherBox: All chicken is GAP animal welfare-certified (though you can’t place single orders)
Many local farms now offer online ordering too. For example, Primal Pastures in California lets you order certified organic, pasture-raised chicken breasts, tenders, and ground meat directly from their website.
4. Mainstream Grocery Stores
Even conventional supermarkets are expanding their organic options! Check the poultry case or frozen section for:
- Perdue Harvestland Organic
- Pilgrim’s Pride Organic
- Tyson NatureRaised Farms Organic
- Simple Truth Organic (Kroger)
While these might not be the absolute highest quality compared to small farms, they’re convenient and more affordable.
5. Costco and Other Warehouse Clubs
Surprise! Costco offers high-quality USDA organic chicken under their Kirkland Signature brand at reasonable prices. Look for:
- Whole organic chickens
- Boneless skinless breasts (often in multipacks)
- Organic ground chicken
Supply varies by location, but the value is hard to beat.
6. Specialty Butcher Shops
Local butchers often source pasture-raised organic chicken from small regional farms. These chickens are frequently air-chilled rather than water-chilled for better taste.
Yes, you’ll pay premium prices, but the quality and personalized service can be worth it. Plus, butchers can offer custom cuts you won’t find in grocery stores.
7. Meal Kit Delivery Services
Companies like Blue Apron and Green Chef now offer meal kits featuring organic chicken. This option combines convenience with quality if you don’t mind paying extra for the service.
8. Trader Joe’s
Trader Joe’s Organic Chicken Breasts come from chickens raised mostly on small family farms following strict USDA Organic Certification rules. It’s a good middle-ground option with reasonable prices.
What to Look for When Buying Organic Chicken
Not all organic chicken is created equal! Here’s what to check for when comparing options:
- Verified labels: Look for the USDA Organic seal or OTA Certified Organic labels
- Pasture access: Terms like “free-range” or “pasture-raised” indicate better outdoor access
- Air-chilled: This processing method retains flavor better than water chilling
- Additional certifications: Look for Certified Humane, Animal Welfare Approved, or GAP certification
- Color: Good quality chicken often has a more yellow-ish tint from natural diet
- Feed quality: “Non-GMO,” “soy-free,” or “omega-3 enriched” feeds are bonus features
Specific Organic Chicken Brands to Look For
Based on quality, availability, and farming practices, these brands stand out:
- Mary’s Organic: Air-chilled organic chicken raised on family farms in California
- Bell & Evans: 100% committed to true organic chicken with excellent welfare standards
- Applegate Organics: Humanely raised, organic chicken products free from antibiotics
- D’Artagnan Organic: Air-chilled for no retained water, humanely raised with no antibiotics or hormones
Is Organic Chicken Worth the Extra Cost?
Let’s be honest—organic chicken costs 20-100% more than conventional chicken. Is it worth it?
For me, the answer is yes, especially for these reasons:
- Better taste (especially from pasture-raised birds)
- Supporting sustainable farming practices
- Avoiding unnecessary antibiotics
- Higher welfare standards for the animals
That said, if budget is tight, here are some cost-saving tips:
- Buy whole chickens and learn to break them down (much cheaper per pound)
- Look for sales and stock up your freezer
- Join a meat CSA for bulk discounts
- Consider mixing conventional and organic depending on the cut and how you’ll use it
FAQ About Buying Organic Chicken
Q: Is organic chicken really healthier?
A: Research shows organic chicken often has higher omega-3 levels and better fatty acid profiles. The lack of antibiotics is also beneficial for reducing antibiotic-resistant bacteria.
Q: Does organic mean the chickens roam freely?
A: Not necessarily. While organic standards require outdoor access, the specifics like acreage and total outdoor time aren’t strictly defined. Look for additional terms like “pasture-raised” for truly free-roaming birds.
Q: How can I tell if chicken is truly organic?
A: Look for the USDA Organic seal, which guarantees the chickens were fed organic feed and raised according to organic standards. For extra assurance, look for farms that welcome visitors or provide transparency about their practices.
Q: Is Trader Joe’s organic chicken really organic?
A: Yes, Trader Joe’s Organic Chicken Breasts come from chickens raised following the USDA Organic Certification rules, mostly on small family farms.
Final Thoughts
Finding good organic chicken doesn’t have to be a wild goose chase (chicken chase?). Whether you prefer the personal connection of buying direct from a local farm, the convenience of online delivery, or just grabbing something quick at your neighborhood grocery store, there are more options than ever for ethically-raised organic poultry.
I’ve personally found that developing relationships with local farmers gives me the most peace of mind about where my food comes from. But on busy weeks, I’m grateful for the organic options at my nearby grocery store too!
Remember, every purchase is a vote for the kind of food system you want to support. By choosing organic chicken when possible, you’re supporting farmers who prioritize animal welfare, environmental sustainability, and human health.
Where do you buy your organic chicken? Have you found a great local source? Share your experiences in the comments below!
This article was last updated September 2025 to reflect the most current information about organic chicken sources.
Where are you sending this gift?
Enter their ZIP code and well make sure the cuts you want to give are available in their area.
Certified organic, sustainably sourced and fully farm traceable. Learn More Family Pack Organic Free Range
Every package is traceable back to the farm where it was raised. We provide details about the farm, the farmers, and their practices—giving you a clear view into the source of your food.
This level of transparency helps build trust and creates a deeper connection to the people and places behind each product.