The Great Chicken Tikka Masala Mystery: Uncovering Its True Origins

Have you ever wondered where your favorite creamy, orange-hued chicken dish actually comes from? If you’re like me, you’ve probably assumed chicken tikka masala is an authentic Indian dish with centuries of tradition behind it. Well, prepare to have your culinary world rocked! The true story behind this beloved dish is far more complex and fascinating than most people realize.

The Contested Origins of Chicken Tikka Masala

Chicken tikka masala has become one of the world’s most popular dishes, found on menus from London to New York to Sydney. But unlike many traditional recipes with clear heritage, this dish’s birthplace is shrouded in mystery and debate. Let’s dive into the competing origin stories and try to separate fact from culinary fiction.

The Glasgow Connection: A Happy Accident?

One of the most widely circulated stories attributes the creation of chicken tikka masala to Ali Ahmed Aslam, a Pakistani chef who owned the Shish Mahal restaurant in Glasgow, Scotland. According to this tale, sometime in the 1970s, a customer complained that his chicken tikka was too dry In response, Chef Aslam improvised by adding a creamy tomato sauce to moisten the dish

The story goes that Aslam created this sauce using:

• Tomato soup (some versions specifically mention Campbell’s tomato soup)
• Cream
• Spices

This impromptu creation supposedly delighted the customer and quickly became a restaurant favorite before spreading throughout Britain and beyond.

However, not everyone buys this story. Peter Grove, a food historian, has challenged Aslam’s claim, noting that the dish existed years before Aslam’s restaurant even opened.

The Bangladeshi Influence in London

Another compelling theory points to Bangladeshi chefs working in London during the 1960s. Following waves of immigration from South Asia, many Bangladeshi cooks found themselves adapting traditional dishes to suit British palates.

These chefs are credited with creating several “inauthentic” Indian dishes specifically designed to appeal to British tastes, with chicken tikka masala potentially being their crowning achievement. The Multicultural Handbook of Food, Nutrition and Dietetics specifically credits Bangladeshi migrant chefs with the dish’s creation.

According to food historians Peter and Colleen Grove, the dish “was most certainly invented in Britain, probably by a Bangladeshi chef.” They suggest that a recipe for “Shahi Chicken Masala” in Mrs Balbir Singh’s Indian Cookery (published in 1961) may have been an influential precursor.

The Indian Origin Theory

Despite the strong evidence pointing to a British creation, some food experts maintain that chicken tikka masala evolved from existing Indian dishes. Rahul Verma, a food critic for The Hindu, has claimed that the dish originated in the Punjab region of India.

The dish does bear a striking resemblance to butter chicken (murgh makhani), a popular Punjabi dish featuring chicken cooked in a creamy tomato sauce. It’s entirely possible that chicken tikka masala represents an evolution or adaptation of this traditional Indian preparation.

What Exactly Is Chicken Tikka Masala?

Before we go further, let’s clarify what defines this contested dish:

Chicken tikka masala consists of:

• Chicken tikka (boneless chicken pieces marinated in yogurt and spices, traditionally cooked in a tandoor)
• A creamy, orange-colored sauce usually made with tomatoes, cream, and various spices
• No standard recipe exists – a survey found that among 48 different recipes, chicken was the ONLY common ingredient!

The dish is similar to butter chicken in both appearance and preparation method, which further complicates determining its true origins.

A Symbol of British Multiculturalism

Whatever its origins, chicken tikka masala has taken on significant cultural importance, particularly in Britain. In fact, in 2001, British Foreign Secretary Robin Cook gave a famous speech in which he declared chicken tikka masala “a true British national dish.”

Cook explained: “Chicken tikka is an Indian dish. The masala sauce was added to satisfy the desire of British people to have their meat served in gravy.”

This characterization of the dish as representing the successful integration of different cultures has made chicken tikka masala more than just food—it’s become a symbol of British multiculturalism and the country’s evolving relationship with its colonial past.

The Fabricated Origin Story?

In an interesting twist, restaurant owner Iqbal Wahhab has claimed that he and Peter Grove actually made up the story about a chef using tomato soup to create chicken tikka masala “to entertain journalists.” This admission further clouds the already murky waters surrounding the dish’s creation.

Chef Anita Jaisinghani wrote in the Houston Chronicle that “the most likely story is that the modern version was created during the early ’70s by an enterprising Indian chef near London” who used Campbell’s tomato soup. But with conflicting accounts, it’s challenging to determine what’s fact and what’s culinary mythology.

Popularity Around the World

Regardless of where it originated, chicken tikka masala has achieved remarkable global popularity:

• It’s served in restaurants worldwide
• According to a 2012 survey, it was Britain’s second-most popular foreign dish to cook at home (after Chinese stir fry)
• It has spawned numerous variations including lamb, fish, and paneer tikka masala

My Take on the Chicken Tikka Masala Debate

After reviewing all the evidence, I’m inclined to believe chicken tikka masala represents a perfect example of culinary fusion—a dish born from the meeting of South Asian cooking techniques and ingredients with British tastes and preferences.

The most plausible scenario seems to be that chefs of South Asian origin (likely Bangladeshi or Pakistani) working in Britain created or perfected the dish sometime in the 1960s or early 1970s. Whether it was specifically Ali Ahmed Aslam, another individual chef, or a more gradual evolution across multiple restaurants remains uncertain.

What’s clear is that chicken tikka masala isn’t an “authentic” centuries-old Indian dish, but rather a relatively recent creation that demonstrates how cuisine evolves when cultures intersect. And isn’t that what makes food history so fascinating?

Make Your Own Chicken Tikka Masala at Home

Want to try making this disputed dish yourself? Here’s a simple approach that captures the essence of chicken tikka masala:

Ingredients:

• 500g boneless chicken pieces
• 1 cup yogurt
• 2 tablespoons ginger-garlic paste
• 1 tablespoon garam masala
• 1 teaspoon turmeric
• 1 teaspoon red chili powder
• 2 tablespoons oil
• 1 onion, finely chopped
• 1 can tomato puree
• 1/2 cup heavy cream
• Salt to taste
• Fresh coriander for garnish

Steps:

1. Marinate chicken in yogurt, half the ginger-garlic paste, and half the spices for at least 2 hours
2. Grill or bake the marinated chicken until cooked through
3. In a separate pan, heat oil and sauté onions until golden
4. Add remaining ginger-garlic paste and spices, cook for 1 minute
5. Add tomato puree and simmer for 10 minutes
6. Stir in cream and add the grilled chicken pieces
7. Simmer for another 5-10 minutes
8. Garnish with fresh coriander and serve with naan or rice

The Legacy Continues

Whether invented in Glasgow, London, or Punjab, chicken tikka masala has transcended its disputed origins to become a beloved global dish. Its story reminds us that culinary innovation often happens at cultural crossroads, and sometimes the most delicious creations emerge from improvisation rather than tradition.

The next time you enjoy a plate of chicken tikka masala, take a moment to appreciate not just its rich flavors but also its rich history as a dish that represents the beautiful complexity of our interconnected culinary world.

So, where does chicken tikka masala truly come from? Perhaps the most honest answer is that it belongs to the world now—a delicious testament to how food evolves when different culinary traditions meet and blend together.

---

Have you tried making chicken tikka masala at home? What’s your favorite version of this dish? Share your experiences in the comments section!

Chicken tikka masala is considered a British dish, having been created by South Asian chefs in the UK to cater to British tastes, rather than being an authentic Indian dish. While the dish features components with roots in the Indian subcontinent, like chicken tikka, the addition of a creamy, tomato-based sauce was a British adaptation that led to its popularity and eventual status as a symbol of Britain’s multiculturalism.

Ali Ahmed Aslam, a Glasgow-based chef and owner of Shish Mahal restaurant, is credited with inventing chicken tikka masala in the 1970s, reportedly by adding a creamy tomato sauce to chicken tikka after a customer complained it was too dry. The dish, a fusion of British and South Asian tastes, emerged from the Indian diaspora in Great Britain and is now considered a national dish of the UK.