Hey y’all! As someone who’s been hunting down the best seafood spots on Tybee Island for years, I’m super excited to share my insider tips on where to get your hands on the freshest shrimp around. Trust me, there’s nothing better than grilling up some juicy local shrimp on your vacation rental’s deck while watching the sunset!
BG’s Seafood Co-Op: The Crown Jewel of Fresh Shrimp
If you’re serious about getting the absolute freshest shrimp possible BG’s Seafood Co-Op is your go-to spot. Here’s why I’m obsessed with this place
- Location: 5 Old US HWY 80, right on Tybee Marina’s docks
- Direct from Boats: Shrimp literally comes straight from the fishing boats to your hands
- Amazing Selection: Beyond shrimp, they’ve got:
- Mahi Mahi
- Flounder
- Red snapper
- Black grouper
- Yellow fin tuna
- Fresh local clams
- Blue crab meat
Pro tip Give ’em a ring at (912)-655-8664 before heading over to check what’s fresh off the boat that day!
Tybee Seafood Market: Your Convenient Shrimp Stop
Located near the pier on Tybrisa Street, this family-run market is perfect when you need a quick shrimp fix. What I love about it:
- Local wild-caught shrimp
- Option to get ’em raw or already boiled
- Super reasonable prices
- Perfect location if you’re staying near the pier
IGA: The One-Stop Shrimp Shop
Sometimes you just need to grab your shrimp while doing other grocery shopping, The island’s IGA has got you covered
- Convenience Factor: Get your shrimp and other groceries in one trip
- Options Galore:
- Fresh shrimp at the counter
- Frozen peeled shrimp
- Sometimes even giant tiger prawns!
Tips for Picking the Perfect Shrimp
Listen up, fam! Here’s how to make sure you’re getting the good stuff:
- The Smell Test: Fresh shrimp should smell like the ocean, not fishy
- The Look Test:
- Should be firm and plump
- Nice bright color
- No grey or black spots
- Buying Guide:
- Plan for 1/4 to 1/2 pound per person
- Get deveined if you’re feeling lazy (no judgment!)
When to Buy Your Shrimp
Pro tip: The earlier in the day you can get to these spots, the better! Most fishing boats come in during the morning hours, so you’ll get first dibs on the freshest catch.
Online Ordering: When You’re Feeling Fancy
For those special occasions or if you’re just not in the mood to shop around, online ordering is an option. Companies like Lobster Anywhere will ship fresh shrimp right to your rental:
- Huge sizes available (8-12 count “Super Colossal”)
- Overnight delivery on ice
- Perfect for special occasions
- Bit pricier but super convenient
My Final Thoughts
Y’all, I can’t stress enough how lucky we are to have such amazing fresh shrimp options on Tybee Island. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, these spots will hook you up with some of the best shrimp you’ve ever tasted.
Remember, the best shrimp is local shrimp, and on Tybee, we’re blessed with some of the sweetest Georgia shrimp you’ll ever taste. Now get out there and start cooking up some seafood magic!
Would you like me to explain or break down any part of this article further?
Also at this address
I visited the Tybee Seafood Matket for the first time last week! I bought a pound of fresh shrimp and a grouper feliet!! Decent price for fresh seafood!! Very friendly staff!! Small selection…
The gentleman working in the seafood market was kind and helpful. We purchased shrimp and 7 mahi mahi filets. Everything was fresh and delicious! Highly recommend!
Yum yum yum! A small selection of local catches. This is newly opened with plans to expand and include a menu, and other produce/goods. Chuck greeted me with such positivity & helped me pick out…
Fresh seafood is hard to beat! These folks are friendly and try to give you what you want.
This place has become my go-to place I buy all my shrimp from. The prices are better than any place Ive been to. The guy is really nice. The shop is clean and smells good, unlike other places…
Where Are The Best Places To Eat On Tybee Island? – Beach Tour Guide
FAQ
How to buy fresh shrimp?
If buying shrimp “fresh”, avoid shrimp (or any seafood) that smells like ammonia – a clear sign that it’s bad. Avoid shells that feel mushy or slimy. If you purchase frozen shrimp, let them defrost slowly in the refrigerator, allowing the water to drain off as they thaw.
What seafood is Tybee Island known for?
Tybee Island is a foodie lover’s paradise filled to the brim with coastal delicacies like shrimp, oysters, crab, and so much more. For those looking to indulge in a flavorful dining experience that’s unmatched elsewhere, add these Tybee Island dishes to your travel wish list.
Does Georgia have fresh seafood?
In addition to fresh finfish and shellfish, other species are harvested or grown in Georgia.
Can you crab on Tybee Island?
The North End of the beach offers surf fishing and on the rocks crabbing. The South End of the beach offers surf fishing and on the rocks crabbing, and fishing and crabbing off the Tybrisa Pier & Pavilion. On the backside of the island(South End), there is a public pier for fishing and crabbing.