If you want to bring an air of sophistication and celebration to your dinner table without spending hours in the kitchen, a surf and turf dinner might be the perfect solution.
With the right ingredients and a bit of planning, you can pull off an effortless meal that looks (and tastes!) over the top—and we’ve got just the recipes to show you how.
Lobster is one of the most prized seafood delicacies. When cooked just right, lobster meat should be tender and succulent with a sweet briny flavor that melts in your mouth. However we’ve all experienced rubbery, chewy lobster at some point. If you’ve had the misfortune of biting into unappetizing, rubbery lobster meat, you likely wondered what went wrong and how it can be avoided next time.
Don’t fret – with a few easy cooking adjustments and preparations, you can ensure your lobster turns out tender and delicious every time. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll uncover the top reasons lobster can turn out rubbery and provide tips to help you achieve flawless texture and taste. You’ll learn how to select, store, prep, and cook lobster properly so you can serve impressive lobster dishes with confidence.
What Causes Rubbery Lobster Meat?
Before jumping into solutions, let’s first review the main culprits that can lead to unappealing chewy or rubbery lobster meat:
-
Overcooking – Cooking the lobster too long causes proteins to become tough and rigid. This is one of the biggest reasons for rubbery meat.
-
Incorrect cooking method – Boiling can make the meat soggy or mushy if done improperly.
-
Old lobster – Meat texture deteriorates as lobster ages after being caught Always cook live lobster as soon as possible,
-
Improper storage – Storing in plastic bags or fresh water removes flavor and causes proteins to break down.
-
Low-quality lobster – Weak, nutrient-deprived lobsters prone to having rubbery texture. Select healthy, active lobsters.
-
Incorrect preparation – Not splitting, tenderizing, or brining appropriately before cooking.
Now that you know the most common causes, let’s review tips to help avoid rubbery lobster every time.
Tips to Prevent Rubbery Lobster
Follow these top tips when handling, prepping, and cooking lobster:
-
Select fresh, active live lobsters – Choose lively lobsters that move claws and tails when handled. Avoid lethargic or sickly looking ones. Select heaviest for size.
-
Store properly – Keep lobsters cool at 35-40°F, but do not freeze if cooking live. Do not store in fresh water or sealed bags.
-
Prep properly – Split tails, remove bands, crack claws before cooking. Consider brining briefly.
-
Avoid overcooking – Test doneness early and often. Lobster overcooks quickly.
-
Use correct cooking method – Steaming is gentler and keeps meat tender. Avoid boiling.
Step-by-Step Instructions for Perfect Lobster
Follow these simple steps for tender, juicy lobster every time:
Ingredients:
- Live lobster(s) or raw lobster tails
- Butter, olive oil, seasoning
- Lemon wedges
Directions:
-
Select fresh active live lobsters and store properly until ready to cook.
-
Prep lobsters before cooking: Split tails, remove bands, crack claws, cut body.
-
Bring water to a full rolling boil if steaming or boiling. Heat broiler, grill or pan if cooking tails/claws.
-
Add lobster to boiling water or steamer and cook for only 2-3 minutes after returning to a boil.
-
Broil, grill or sauté tails/claws for 3-4 minutes per side until opaque. Baste with butter.
-
Check for doneness frequently. Meat should be opaque white, not translucent. Remove immediately to prevent overcooking.
-
Serve with melted butter, lemon wedges, fresh herbs, etc. Enjoy immediately for tender texture.
The key is to not overcomplicate preparation and cooking. Follow these guidelines for selecting, storing, prepping and cooking properly, and you’ll be rewarded with tender, succulent lobster meat every time.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can you tell when lobster is overcooked?
Overcooked lobster will be tough, chewy, and rubbery. The meat will be opaque and dry rather than creamy white and moist when properly cooked.
What is the best way to cook lobster tails?
For tender lobster tails, steam, broil, or grill them. Split shells prior to cooking and baste with butter while broiling or grilling.
Why does boiled lobster get rubbery?
Boiling can make lobster meat soggy and mushy if cooked too long. It also lacks the caramelization of grilling or broiling.
Should you boil or steam whole lobster?
Steaming is gentler and helps retain moisture better. But boiling infuses flavor if done properly. Both work if you don’t overcook.
How long should I boil pre-cooked lobster tails?
Boil pre-cooked frozen tails just 2-3 minutes to heat through and prevent rubbery texture from overcooking.
Conclusion
Avoiding rubbery lobster is easy with proper handling and cooking. Follow the recommendations in this guide for selecting, storing, prepping and cooking lobster correctly, and you can feel confident your next lobster feast will impress everyone with tender, juicy meat.
The key is preventing overcooking, using the right cooking methods like steaming or broiling, and testing for doneness frequently. Master these lobster cooking tips and you’ll be serving up tender, delicious lobster in no time.
Steak and Lobster Tails
If you’re really aiming to impress, serve up restaurant-quality steak and lobster for dinner. A brilliant red lobster tail makes a statement on the plate. Add a homemade oven-broiled steak and you have an all-around winning combination for every palate that’ll satisfy even the most pretentious New England seafood chef.
We make this show-stopping dinner easy to pull off with our ready-to-prepare Captain’s Tails and Turf package. This combo includes two buttery-soft fillets with the meatiest Atlantic cold water lobster tails and a zesty key lime pie to finish things off.
Here’s how to prepare steak and lobster tails for dinner:
First, prep and season your lobster.
- Make a deep lengthwise cut in the top of the lobster tails.
- Gently pry the shells apart and season the meat with melted butter and a sprinkle of salt and pepper. If you like, you can add a dusting of Old Bay seasoning, smoked paprika, or any dried herb you love.
(For more tips on how to properly prepare lobster, Checkout our recipe How to cook Lobster Tails .)
Meanwhile, fire up your broiler to high and prepare the steaks.
- Place an oven rack two to three inches from the heat source.
- Place the steaks on a baking sheet and generously season both sides with salt and pepper.
- Place the baking sheet under the broiler.
- Use this chart to determine the best cooking time for your steaks.
- Remove the steaks from the oven just before they reach your desired doneness, transfer to a cutting board, cover with aluminum foil, and let the meat rest while you broil the lobster.
Cook the lobster.
- Place the prepared lobster tails on the same baking sheet.
- Place them under the broiler and cook until the meat is opaque, about 5 to 10 minutes.
Finally, plate everything up and dig in!
Steak and scallops might be a more unusual approach to surf and turf, but it still fits the bill. In fact, plump, fresh sea scallops have a soft and flaky texture that pairs well with steak.
Since scallops are so naturally buttery on their own, you can swap the more traditional fillet with a high-quality New York strip steak.
This surf and turf pairing calls for the stovetop. Use a large, heavy-bottomed cast-iron pan or skillet to sear both your steaks and scallops.
Here’s how to cook it:
- First, pat the scallops and steaks dry with paper towels and season both sides with salt and pepper. Brush them with a thin coating of canola oil or another high-heat oil.
- Heat your pan over medium-high heat for a good 3 to 5 minutes, until hot.
- Gently place the steaks in the skillet and sear for 4 minutes, or until you have a nice brown crust on one side. Use tongs to flip the steaks and cook for 3 to 4 minutes on the other side.
- Add a 2-tablespoon pat of butter to the skillet and as it melts, spoon the butter over the steaks for another minute.
- Remove the steaks from the skillet when they are 5 to 10 degrees away from your desired doneness. Place on a cutting board, cover with aluminum foil, and rest while you sear the scallops.
- Return the skillet to medium-high heat.
- When the oil is hot, gently place the scallops into the skillet, leaving several inches of space between each scallop.
- Sear for 2 minutes undisturbed, then add 1 tablespoon of butter to and gently flip the scallops with tongs or a thin fish spatula to sear for another minute, until cooked through but still soft in the center.
Plate up your steaks and scallops and serve hot!
Best Surf and Turf Recipes
To get your planning process started, here are some of the best surf and turf pairings to try at home. These pairings are restaurant-quality and easier than you might think to pull together.
Steak and shrimp is a beloved surf and turf pairing. Shrimp are naturally sweet and light to balance the richness of the steak. Plus, perfectly cooked shrimp add a nice pop of pale pink to the plate for an effortless (and edible) decoration.
Filet mignon is the perfect accompaniment to large, juicy shrimp. This buttery-soft cut is tender and juicy when cooked on the grill. Use our tips to know the exact moment to pull your steaks from the flames.
And while you have the grill fired up, assemble your shrimp on skewers for a quick and easy preparation. If you choose large shrimp two or three per person should be sufficient with the steak.
And if you plan to serve the shrimp on the skewer, opt for short wooden skewers that will fit nicely on your dinner plates. Be sure to soak the wood for at least 30 minutes before grilling to prevent charring.
When you’re ready to cook:
- Preheat a gas or charcoal grill over medium-high heat.
- Pat your steaks and shrimp dry and season both sides with salt and pepper. Brush with a thin coating of neutral oil.
- Place the steaks on the grill and cook according to the times in this chart, flipping once with tongs.
- After you’ve removed the steak to rest, place the shrimp skewers on the grill for 1 to 2 minutes per side.
- Remove the shrimp when they are bright pink and curled into a “C” shape. Keep a close eye on the shrimp, as they cook quickly.
Or, If you like, you can add a boost of flavor by marinating the shrimp for 15 minutes in a simple mixture of:
- Citrus juice (lemon, orange or lime juice)
- A teaspoon of dried herbs (basil, oregano, thyme or parsley)
- A minced garlic clove.
While you can technically use any size shrimp for surf and turf, you’ll get the most flavor and a stunning presentation with colossal shrimp. These are best for grilling as they can withstand direct heat without overcooking or turning rubbery. Plus, they won’t fall through the grates!
Also Read: Shrimp Sizing Guide: Large, Jumbo, Colossal, And Beyond