Learning how to cook frozen lobster tails is relatively easy. The hard part will be deciding which way to prepare them—in the oven, grill, air fryer, or pot. Whether planning a special event or to have on hand, you can order fresh lobster tails ahead of time online and then freeze them yourself. That way, you will know when the lobster tails are frozen – they will keep up to three months before the risk of freezer burn.
Lobster tails are a delicious and luxurious seafood treat that can seem intimidating for home cooks. Thankfully with the right techniques you can easily make restaurant-quality lobster tails using frozen tails you find at the grocery store. In this comprehensive guide, I’ll walk you through everything you need to know to cook frozen lobster tails perfectly every time.
Choosing High-Quality Frozen Lobster Tails
The first step is selecting high-quality frozen tails that will give you the best results Here’s what to look for
-
Cold water lobster – Choose tails labeled as cold water lobster rather than warm water. The meat will be sweeter, more tender, and less prone to mushiness.
-
Flash frozen – Look for tails that were frozen rapidly at peak freshness to lock in flavor and texture. Avoid any with signs of freezer burn
-
Size 5-6 ounces – Smaller tails cook more evenly than jumbo 10+ ounce tails when cooked from frozen.
-
Color – Opt for tails with bright red shells and white meat without discoloration or yellow spots.
Choosing the right frozen tails will make a huge difference in getting tender, juicy, flavorful results.
Thawing Frozen Lobster Tails
While you can cook frozen lobster tails without thawing, thawing first is ideal for the most tender texture. Here are safe ways to thaw tails:
-
Fridge thawing – Place tails in a single layer in a rimmed plate or pan. Thaw overnight in the fridge for 10-12 hours.
-
Cold water thaw – Seal tails in a plastic bag and submerge in cold water. Change water every 30 mins. Thaw time 30-60 mins.
Do not thaw lobster tails on the counter or in hot water, which breeds bacteria. Fridge thawing is slowest but safest.
Preparing Lobster Tails for Cooking
Once thawed, prepare your tails:
-
Split the shell – Use kitchen shears to cut through the top shell lengthwise without cutting the meat.
-
Loosen the meat – Insert a spoon to loosen the meat away from the bottom shell.
-
Season the meat – Brush with oil or melted butter and season with salt, pepper, garlic, lemon, etc.
Proper prep helps the lobster cook evenly and absorbs maximum flavor.
Cooking Methods for Frozen Lobster Tails
With prepped tails ready, it’s time to cook. Here are popular methods:
Broiling
-
Place tails shell-side down on a broiler pan. Broil 4-5 minutes until shells redden.
-
Flip and broil 2-3 minutes more until opaque.
Grilling
-
Oil shells and grill shell-side down 4-5 minutes over high heat.
-
Flip tails and grill 2-3 minutes until meat is opaque.
Pan Searing
-
Pat tails dry and sear shell-side down in a very hot pan for 3-4 minutes.
-
Flip and cook 2 more minutes until opaque.
Boiling
-
Add tails to boiling salted water and simmer 4-6 minutes until shells redden.
-
Cook time varies on size, about 1 minute per ounce.
Baking
- Place oiled tails on a baking sheet at 425°F for 12-15 minutes until meat firms.
For all methods, check doneness by cutting into the thickest part of a tail. The meat should be opaque throughout.
Tips for Cooking from Frozen
-
Reduce cook times by 1-2 minutes compared to thawed.
-
Cook smaller tails for more even results. Jumbo tails may be underdone in center.
-
Use hot, direct heat cooking methods to rapidly thaw and cook.
-
Brush shells with oil or butter to help conduct heat into the meat.
With the right techniques, you can cook frozen tails to tender perfection.
Serving Your Homemade Lobster Tails
Once your lobster tails are cooked to tender, juicy perfection, it’s time to dig in! Here are some delicious ways to serve them:
-Classic with melted lemon butter for dipping
-Surf and turf with a juicy steak
-In lobster rolls served on split-top buns
-Over pasta with a creamy garlic Alfredo sauce
-On lobster tacos with avocado, pico de gallo, and cilantro
-On a lobster Cobb salad with avocado, bacon, egg, and blue cheese
-On lobster mac and cheese for a rich, decadent main dish
The possibilities are endless for enjoying these luxurious lobster tails. Cook them simply with just lemon and butter or incorporate them into flavorful composed dishes and meals.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cooking Frozen Lobster Tails
How can you tell if frozen tails are fresh?
Look for bright red shells without dark spots or yellowing. Avoid freezer burned packages with ice crystals or dry, dehydrated patches.
Is it better to thaw before cooking?
Yes, thawing helps prevent overcooking and yields the most tender meat. Fridge thawing overnight is best.
What happens if you cook frozen tails without thawing?
The meat near the shell may overcook while the center stays icy. Smaller tails have more even results.
How long do you cook frozen lobster tails?
Cook 1-2 minutes less than thawed. Grill or broil 4-5 minutes per side. Boil 1 minute per ounce.
What size frozen tails are best?
5-6 ounce tails cook the most evenly from frozen. Larger tails have a higher risk of uneven cooking.
Can you re-freeze lobster tails after thawing?
No, thawed tails cannot be safely re-frozen at home. Cook thawed tails within 1-2 days.
What are the best cooking methods?
Quick, hot methods like grilling, broiling, and pan searing give the best results. Steaming also works well.
Why Buy Fresh Lobster (and Freeze Yourself!)
While frozen lobster tails offer convenience, nothing beats the taste and quality of fresh lobster. Fresh Maine lobster boasts a sweeter, more delicate flavor with tender and succulent meat. The texture of fresh lobster is unmatched, delivering that quintessential burst of ocean-fresh goodness in every bite. Freezing can alter the lobster’s natural taste and consistency. While frozen tails are a good option in a pinch, they often lack the full-bodied flavor profile that makes fresh lobster such a sought-after delicacy.
For those looking to experience the finest lobster, Klenda Seafood offers premium fresh Maine lobster straight from the cold waters of the Atlantic. Sourced daily and delivered with care, our fresh lobster provides an unparalleled dining experience. Whether you’re preparing a special meal or simply indulging in the best seafood Maine has to offer, shop with Klenda Seafood to enjoy lobster the way it’s meant to be: fresh and flavorful.