Cooking salmon with the skin on or off is a debated topic among home cooks. The skin contains a lot of flavorful fats and oils, so leaving it on can make the fish more moist and tender. However, the skin can also make the salmon more difficult to cook properly. Read on as we explore the pros and cons of cooking salmon with the skin on versus off.
The Benefits of Cooking Salmon with the Skin On
Here are some of the main advantages of cooking salmon fillets skin-side down:
-
More moisture and flavor. The skin contains natural oils that keep the salmon juicy as it cooks. Leaving it on prevents the delicate fish from drying out As the skin crisps, it also adds texture and rich, savory flavor.
-
Prevents sticking. The skin helps the fish not stick to the pan or grill. The natural fats in the skin keep it from adhering to hot surfaces.
-
Added nutrition Salmon skin contains heart-healthy omega-3 fatty acids Leaving it on allows you to get the most nutritional benefit from the fish.
-
Beautiful presentation. When cooked properly salmon skin becomes gorgeously crispy and golden brown. Serving salmon fillets skin-side up makes for an elegant presentation.
-
Easier to flip. The skin makes the fillet more stable, making it easier to flip halfway through cooking. Skinless salmon is more prone to falling apart.
So in terms of flavor and ease of cooking, there are some clear advantages to leaving the skin on. However, it does require a bit of technique to get the skin perfectly crisp.
Potential Drawbacks of Cooking Salmon with Skin
Here are a few of the potential pitfalls of cooking skin-on salmon:
-
Undercooked skin. If the skin doesn’t render out enough, it can remain flabby and unappetizing. Achieving crispy salmon skin takes high heat and focus.
-
Overcooked fish. It’s easy to burn the skin while the inside of the fillet remains underdone. Monitoring temperature is key.
-
Sticking skin. If the pan isn’t hot enough or has insufficient oil, the skin can fuse to it. Proper preparation prevents this.
-
Mouthfeel. Some people find the texture of skin unappealing. It can also get stuck in teeth.
-
More work. Removing pinbones and excess fat takes more time and care with skin-on cuts.
-
Higher calorie. The extra fats in the skin make it a higher-calorie way to prepare salmon. Portion size matters if watching calories.
So cooking salmon skin-on does take some finesse. But the advantages seem to outweigh the potential issues for most home cooks.
Tips for Cooking Salmon with Crispy Skin
Follow these simple tips for achieving beautifully cooked salmon with crispy skin every time:
-
Use skin-on fillets. Choose thick, center-cut salmon fillets with the skin still attached. The fattier belly flaps are harder to crisp up.
-
Season well. Rub the skin side with oil and season generously with salt and pepper. Sprinkled spices also add flavor.
-
Get the pan very hot. Use a heavy skillet over medium-high heat. Make sure the oil is shimmering before adding fish.
-
Skin-side down first. Place the fillets skin-side down in the hot pan. Cook for 3-5 minutes undisturbed.
-
Monitor color. Once the skin looks crispy and golden brown, flip and finish cooking on the flesh side.
-
Check temperature. Cook until the thickest part of the fish reaches 125°F for medium-rare.
-
Let rest before serving. The temperature will continue increasing off heat for juicy results.
-
Remove skin before eating if desired. Use a thin, flexible spatula to separate it from the cooked fish.
Should You Cook Salmon Skin-Side Up or Down?
Cooking the salmon skin-side down first is key. This allows the fatty skin to render and become crispy. If you cook it skin-side up the whole time, the skin will never get crispy and flavorful. Flipping it halfway through ensures even cooking.
If using a broiler or grill, you can start with the skin side up. The high overhead heat will help the skin crisp as the fish cooks through. Just watch it closely to prevent burning.
Should You Remove the Skin Before Eating?
This comes down to personal preference. The skin adds great texture and flavor. But some find it unappealing.
For the best results, cook the salmon with the skin on. Then remove it after cooking if desired. Use a thin spatula to separate the skin from the moist flesh before serving.
The Takeaway: Worth the Extra Effort
It takes a bit more care and attention to detail to achieve perfectly crispy salmon skin. But the payoff of added moisture, flavor, and nutrition is worth it. Follow the tips above for foolproof crispy skin every time.
The skin adds so much flavor that it’s best to cook salmon with it on. But you can always remove it after cooking if you prefer to enjoy the tender fish on its own. Cooked properly, salmon skin is a real treat – so consider leaving it on and savoring its savory crispiness. With a bit of practice, you’ll become a pro at cooking salmon with deliciously crisped skin.
Cook Your Salmon Skin-Side Down
For many years, I worked as a private chef in Manhattan and my clients requested seared salmon at least once per week. Like the rule follower I am, I used the ‘presentation-side’ down method many, many times, but found very little success. During these busy evenings, I was usually juggling many different items at once, all on my own. As they say, sometimes you have to sink before you swim, or in this case, cook your salmon skin-side down and break all the rules.
Here me out, when you cook the salmon skin-side down, it gives a visual and audible cue of when the fish is ready to flip. When the skin hits the pan, you can see it start to shrink up and render fat. You’ll also notice the oil bubble when you first add the fish to the pan. Once it starts to quiet down, you’ll know the skin has released and you are ready to flip.
Plus, it’s much easier to get a spatula under the crispy skin, rather than the delicate flesh, when you go in for the flip. Last but not least, since the pan is already nice and hot, the presentation side cooks evenly without any sticking, and you still get the beautiful brown sear after all.
What If You Like To Bake Your Salmon?
If you prefer to bake your salmon, the same tip applies. The skin helps protect the salmon from sticking to the pan during the slow cooking process. The only downside of this method in the oven is the skin will not crisp up, but I usually just serve it without the skin in this case. Sometimes it pays off to be a rule breaker in the kitchen.
The Food Lab: How to Make Pan-Fried Salmon Fillets With Crispy Skin
FAQ
Is it better to cook salmon with the skin on or off?
The insulative subcutaneous fat acts as a heat barrier, transmitting heat to the interior flesh very, very slowly. This slow heat transfer means that skin-on salmon cooks much more evenly and gently than skinless salmon.
What are the benefits of leaving skin on salmon?
Always keep the skin on when buying salmon. It adds flavor, picks up char from the grill or pan, helps protect the fish from overcooking, prevents sticking, and is your best chance for keeping the delicate flesh intact. Remove the Bones as Needed.
Is salmon better for you with or without skin?
The skin of a salmon contains the highest concentration of omega-3 fatty acids on the fish. So it is healthy to eat the skin of salmon.
Should you cook salmon skin-on?
It ultimately comes down to personal preference. Cooking salmon skin-on offers several advantages: Flavor and Texture: The skin adds a delightful layer of crispy texture and savory flavor to the dish. As the salmon cooks, the fat renders from the skin, creating a succulent and flavorful experience.
Should you cook salmon with or without skin?
In conclusion, whether you should cook salmon with or without its skin depends on your personal preference. If you prefer a crispy texture and enhanced flavor, then leave the skin on while cooking. However, if you’re concerned about potential toxins and want a more visually appealing dish, then remove the skin before cooking.
How to cook salmon skin off?
Cooking salmon skin-off is a straightforward process: 1. Prepare the Salmon: Remove the skin from the salmon fillets and pat them dry with paper towels. 2. Seasoning: Season the salmon generously with salt, pepper, and other desired spices. 3. Heat the Pan: Heat a skillet or oven-safe pan over medium heat. 4.
Why do you cook salmon with skin on?
Retains Moisture: Cooking salmon with the skin on helps to retain moisture in the fish while it cooks. This means that the flesh will be juicier and more tender. Easier Cooking: Leaving the skin on makes it easier to cook salmon without worrying about it falling apart during the cooking process.
Can you cook salmon with the skin on one side?
Cooking salmon with the skin on one side is a technique that enriches the flavor, maintains moisture, and offers a delightful texture. By following the steps outlined in this guide, you can enjoy perfectly cooked salmon that impresses your family and guests alike.
Should salmon skin be on or on the bottom?
The benefit to keeping the skin on and on the bottom is protecting the salmon itself from the heat, he says. The skin itself is protective, and there’s a layer of fat between it and the flesh that also helps ensure that the bottom of the salmon is softer in texture, compared to the crispy skin.