If you want to bring an air of sophistication and celebration to your dinner table without spending hours in the kitchen, a surf and turf dinner might be the perfect solution.
With the right ingredients and a bit of planning, you can pull off an effortless meal that looks (and tastes!) over the top—and we’ve got just the recipes to show you how.
Lobster is one of the most prized seafood delicacies, loved for its tender meat and sweet, briny flavor. But before you can enjoy this luxurious shellfish, an important decision must be made – is it better to steam or boil your lobster? This age-old cooking debate has lobster lovers firmly entrenched in their preferred camp.
In this detailed guide, we’ll examine the pros, cons, and key differences between steaming and boiling lobster. You’ll learn how to perfectly execute both cooking methods. We’ll also provide tips on preparing, seasoning, and serving your lobster to highlight the best qualities of each technique. After reading this, you’ll be able to decide whether steaming or boiling is best for you.
Understanding Lobster Biology
Before we dive into the debate it’s essential to understand a bit about lobster biology. Lobsters are crustaceans belonging to the family Nephropidae. They have a complex nervous system, which includes a brain, ventral nerve cord, and sensory organs. This nervous system allows them to perceive and respond to their environment, including pain and stress.
Lobsters also have a unique physiology, with a hard exoskeleton that protects their internal organs They have claws, which they use for defense, and a tail that they use for swimming and balance. Lobsters are also highly social creatures, often living in large groups in the wild
Steaming Lobster
Steaming is a gentle slower cooking method that helps retain moisture texture, and flavor. Here’s an overview of steaming technique:
- Fill a large pot with 1-2 inches of water and bring to a boil. Use seasoned water or sea water.
- Place a steamer basket or rack in the pot. Make sure the lobster will fit without overcrowding.
- Once the water is rapidly boiling, place live lobster in the basket, cover, and start timing.
- Steam for 7 minutes per pound for the first pound. Add 3 minutes per pound for each additional pound.
- Check for doneness by looking for an opaque, pearly white interior when cracking open the body or tail.
Benefits of Steaming Lobster
- Preserves delicate flavor and texture of the meat.
- Less likelihood of overcooking and drying out the meat.
- Keeps more nutrients intact compared to boiling.
- Allows seasoning and aromatics to be added to the steaming liquid.
- Tail meat slides out of the shell easily when served.
- Gently coagulates the proteins resulting in a silky texture.
Downsides of Steaming Lobster
- Takes more time than boiling.
- Can be tricky to get timing right.
- Need the right equipment (steamer setup).
- Does not produce that bright red shell color that some people expect.
- Does not infuse the meat with as much saline flavor as boiling.
Boiling Lobster
Boiling is a faster, more aggressive cooking method where the lobster is submerged and simmered in boiling hot liquid. Here are some tips for boiling lobster:
- Use a large pot and fill with salted water. Allow at least 3 quarts of water per 1.5 pounds of lobster.
- Bring the salted water to a rapid boil before adding lobster.
- Gently lower live lobsters head-first into the boiling water.
- Once returned to a boil, start timing and boil for 8-12 minutes per pound.
- For flavor, add herbs, garlic, or citrus to the boiling water.
- Check for doneness by looking for bright red shell and opaque interior meat.
Benefits of Boiling Lobster
- Very quick and simple cooking method.
- Useful for cooking large batches of lobster.
- Bright red shell and white meat is visually appealing.
- Draws out more saline, briny flavor from the shell.
- Firm texture makes it easy to crack the shell and extract meat.
Downsides of Boiling Lobster
- Can easily overcook and dry out the meat.
- Immersed heat can toughen proteins more than steaming.
- Not as forgiving if you need to hold for service before eating.
- Leaches more flavor from the meat into the boiling liquid.
- Can kill live lobsters more harshly if not lowered gently into the pot.
Comparing Steamed vs Boiled Lobster
So when it comes to choosing between steaming and boiling lobster, which method wins out? Here is a direct comparison of some key considerations:
| Factor | Steamed | Boiled |
|---|---|---|
| Prep Time | Longer | Faster |
| Cook Time | 18-20 minutes per lb | 8-12 minutes per lb |
| Equipment Needed | Steamer setup | Large pot |
| Ease of Execution | Moderate | Easy |
| Texture | Silky, translucent | Opague, firm |
| Flavor | Delicate, subtle | Enhanced brininess |
| Moisture Retention | Excellent | Moderate |
| Nutrient Retention | High | Moderate |
| Shell Color | Orange-red | Bright red |
Choosing the Right Cooking Method
When deciding between steaming and boiling your lobster, keep these tips in mind:
- If time is limited or cooking large amounts, boiling may be best.
- For special occasions or perfect texture/flavor, opt for steaming.
- If presentation is key, boiling produces that iconic red color.
- If you’ll hold lobster after cooking, steaming is more forgiving.
- For beginners, boiling is easier and more foolproof.
- Steaming requires a bit more lobster cooking skill.
Steaming and Boiling Tips
Here are some extra pointers to improve your results when steaming and boiling lobster:
- For both methods, make sure lobsters are alive right before cooking.
- Clean any debris from the shell but don’t scrub the shell.
- Remove rubber bands on claws before cooking if desired.
- Plunge cooked lobsters into an ice bath to stop cooking if needed.
- Add lemon, garlic, herbs, white wine or seaweed when boiling or steaming.
- Serve with clarified butter or aioli for dipping the meat.
- Split lobsters before serving or provide lobster crackers and picks.
- Don’t discard the tomalley (liver) – it’s delicious!
Preparing Lobster for Cooking
Proper preparation is key to cooking lobster perfectly, whether you are steaming or boiling. Here are some tips:
- Choose live lobsters and cook as soon as possible for optimal freshness.
- Look for lively lobsters that curl their tails and claws when handled.
- Store live lobsters in a ventilated box in the coldest part of your fridge until ready to cook.
- Prior to cooking, rinse lobsters under cold running water to remove any debris.
- Use sharp kitchen shears to split live lobsters or lobster tails before cooking.
- Remove the small legs to prevent them from burning and overcooking.
- Pick larger lobsters for boiling and smaller ones for steaming.
- Pat lobsters dry thoroughly before steaming or boiling.
- Double check your timing and doneness indicators for perfectly cooked lobster.
Hopefully this guide has helped shed light on the steaming versus boiling decision. When prepared properly, both methods can produce tender, succulent lobster worthy of any feast. Gather your ingredients, prep your lobsters, and get ready to enjoy mouthwatering shellfish. Just be ready for hot debate amongst your guests about which cooking technique reigns supreme. But as long as everyone is happy with their delicious lobster, that’s all that matters!
How to Plan a Surf and Turf Menu
To put together a surf and turf menu of your own, start with a bit of planning to make sure your dinner comes together perfectly.
One of the best parts about surf and turf is that you can often cook both the meat and seafood in the same pan, which means less mess. Whether you use a grill, broiler, or stovetop, you can first sear the meat, then quickly cook the seafood while your steak rests.
First, choose your surf and your turf entrees. The most classic surf and turf menus feature red meat, often steak. However, if you’re not a fan or don’t eat red meat, you can certainly substitute steak for some chicken or pork.
| If you want to stand out even more, put your own spin on turf entree with a unique protein like lamb or duck. There really are no rules, so now’s your time to experiment in the kitchen! |
|---|
Likewise, for the surf side of things, you have plenty of options. The most classic and extravagant surf and turf plates feature a bold red lobster, either whole or just the tail. Sometimes the tail is stuffed for added visual and flavor appeal. Other surf options include succulent shrimp, seared scallops, crab cakes, or your favorite fish fillet.
Finally, round out your surf and turf menu with one or two side dishes. These don’t have to be complicated or overdone. The meat and seafood are the stars of the show, so the sides are the supporting actors there to help the proteins shine. See below for the best side dish ideas to pair with your surf and turf.
What is Surf and Turf?
Surf and turf is a style of menu that offers the best of both the land and the sea. This means customers don’t have to choose between the steak and the lobster and just get them both. This is a classic offering at steakhouses and seafood restaurants.
Surf and turf plates are often show-stopping displays of vibrant, fresh seafood and juicy seared steak. Alongside the main course, you’ll often find vegetable side dishes like crisp green asparagus, creamed spinach, whipped potatoes, or other sides to balance out all the protein.
Ultimately, surf and turf is a delightful culinary experience of texture, flavor, and aroma in one unique meal.
Is it better to steam or boil lobster tails?
FAQ
Are lobsters better steamed or boiled?
Boiling can cause a mess, and steaming reduces boilovers. Generally, boiling helps cook more evenly and is best if you’re cooking more than four lobsters.
How long does it take to steam a lobster?
- Bring water to a rolling boil in a large pot or steamer.
- Add the lobster to the boiling water, ensuring they are alive.
- Cover the pot tightly and start timing.
- Check for doneness by observing the shell color and cracking a joint to inspect the meat, according to Seafood University.
Does boiling lobster make it taste better?
Flavor: Boiling tends to preserve the natural sweetness and delicate flavor of the lobster meat. The meat remains moist and tender, as it is cooked evenly in hot water. Texture: The texture is generally soft and buttery. Boiling helps maintain the lobster’s natural juiciness.
Is it better to boil or cook lobster?
On the downside, cooking takes longer than boiling and requires a unique pot, which not everyone may have in their kitchen. Boiling, on the other hand, is a quick and easy way to cook lobster. It’s as simple as bringing a pot of salted water to a boil, dropping in the lobster, and letting it cook for a few minutes.
Should you cook lobster steamed or boiled?
Lobster that is steamed is more tender as less water infiltrates the shells. If you have a crowd of people, boiling is the way to go, as it’s the best method for cooking four or more lobsters at one time. LobsterAnywhere.com cites the main advantage here is the high, intense heat from the boiling water.
What are the pros and cons of steaming lobster?
Let’s dive into the pros and cons of each method so you can decide which suits your taste buds better. Steaming lobster is a delicate process that retains all the flavor and tenderness of the meat. Since the lobster is cooked with steam, it doesn’t lose any of its juices or nutrients.
How do you cook a lobster in a steamer?
Steaming a lobster involves placing the lobster in a steamer basket and cooking over boiling water. When burning a lobster, bring a pot of heavily salted water to a boil before adding the lobster. Cover the pot and cook for 8-10 minutes, depending on the size of the lobster. The cooking time is typically the same as burning.
How do you boil a live lobster?
Boiling lobster is a quick and easy way to cook a delicious seafood meal. Bring a large pot of heavily salted water to a rolling boil to get started. Once the water is hot, add your live lobsters headfirst and cover the pot tightly. Let the water return to a spot as quickly as possible to ensure even cooking.
Why do you steam lobster?
Steaming lobster is a delicate process that retains all the flavor and tenderness of the meat. Since the lobster is cooked with steam, it doesn’t lose any of its juices or nutrients. Steaming is less likely to overcook the lobster, leaving it moist and succulent.