Cooking lobster at home can seem intimidating, but with the right pot, it’s easier than you think. The pot is one of the most important factors in achieving tender, perfectly cooked lobster meat. The size, shape, and material of the pot impact cooking times, flavor, and how evenly the lobster cooks.
In this guide, we’ll walk through the key considerations for picking the ideal pot to cook whole live lobsters, lobster tails, or frozen lobster meat. Whether you’re cooking lobster for the first time or looking to improve your technique, read on for pro tips to help you master lobster pots.
How Does the Pot Affect Lobster Cooking?
The pot influences several aspects of cooking lobster
-
Size – The pot must be large enough for lobsters to move freely during cooking Overcrowding prevents even heating
-
Shape – Tall, narrow pots boil faster while wide pots allow more steam release. Choose based on burner size.
-
Material – Good conductors like stainless steel and aluminum distribute heat quickly for fast, even cooking
-
Weight – Heavier pots retain heat well once hot. Lightweight pots heat rapidly but temperatura drops quickly.
Considering these factors allows you to dial in the perfect pot for your stovetop and cooking style. Keep reading for details on picking the best size, shape, and material for cooking lobsters.
Choosing the Right Size Pot for Lobsters
Pot size is critical to prevent overcrowding and ensure even cooking. As a rule of thumb:
-
4-6 quarts per 1-1.5 pound lobster – Allows room for heat circulation.
-
12-15 quarts for 2 lobsters – Enough space so they don’t touch.
-
20+ quarts for 4-6 lobsters – Ample room for multiple crustaceans.
Match the pot size to the number and size of lobsters you’re cooking. It’s better to cook in batches in multiple smaller pots than overload one large one.
Steamers and multi-cookers with separators allow fitting more lobsters in less space. Still, make sure claws and tails have breathing room.
If cooking lobster tails or frozen lobster meat, a 1-2 quart saucepan is sufficient.
How Material Affects Cooking Performance
The pot material impacts heating efficiency, cooking time, flavor, and ease of handling:
-
Stainless Steel – Durable, non-reactive, and distributes heat evenly. Excellent conductivity.
-
Aluminum – Affordable, lightweight, and heats rapidly. Prone to warping over time.
-
Enameled Cast Iron – Retains heat well and creates a humid environment ideal for steaming. Heavy.
-
Uncoated Cast Iron – Can impart metallic flavors. Requires seasoning. Heavy for handling.
-
Nonstick – Not ideal for high heat lobster cooking. Coating can degrade and leach chemicals.
For most home cooks, stainless steel offers the best balance of even heating, durability, and ease of use. Aluminum is more budget-friendly but less sturdy over time.
How Pot Shape Impacts Lobster Cooking
Two main factors related to pot shape affect cooking:
Height – Tall, narrow pots concentrate heat and water for rapid boiling. Great for speed.
Width – Wide, shallow pots allow steam release for thicker broth. Requires more monitoring.
Consider your goals, stove space, and preferences when deciding on pot height and width. If cooking time is critical, go tall and narrow. For more broth flavor, choose wide and shallow.
Matching the pot base to burner size improves efficiency. Small pots on large burners waste heat, while large pots overflow small burners.
Pro Tips for Selecting Lobster Pots
Keep these expert tips in mind when selecting a pot for lobsters:
-
Target straight sides over curved to maximize cooking space.
-
Look for sturdy handles that can safely lift a heavy boiling pot.
-
Match pot size to burner dimensions for fastest heating.
-
Lids trap steam and moisture crucial for even cooking.
-
Pour spouts simplify draining hot water after cooking.
-
Buy a separate pot just for cooking lobsters to prevent flavor transfer.
With the right gear and techniques, you can achieve restaurant-quality results cooking lobsters at home.
Recommended Pot Types for Lobster
Here are the best pot varieties for preparing perfect lobster:
Stock Pots
The classic lobster cooking pot. Look for:
-
12+ quart capacity
-
Encapsulated base prevents scorching
-
Helper handles provide control and safety
-
Steamer basket recommended
Pasta Pots
Designed to boil water rapidly. Great features:
-
20+ quart size fits 4+ lobsters
-
Steamer insert or colander accessories
-
Long handles and pouring spouts
-
Tight-fitting lid traps steam
Seafood Cookers/Canners
Massive pots made for lobster. What to look for:
-
20-80 quart capacity
-
Vertical ridges to elevate steamer basket
-
Drain spigot for easy pouring
-
Industrial grade stainless construction
Steamer Pots
Gently cook lobster in steam:
-
Wide base produces ample steam
-
Tight lid locks in moisture
-
Insert prevents direct contact with boiling water
Multi-Cookers
Allow cooking multiple foods:
-
Dividers to separate lobster from vegetables
-
Inserts customize boiling, steaming, etc.
-
Compact all-in-one design
Lobster Pot FAQs
Here are answers to some frequently asked questions about cooking lobsters in pots:
What’s the best metal for lobster pots?
Stainless steel and aluminum are ideal. Avoid uncoated cast iron or pots with nonstick coating.
What size pot fits one lobster?
Use a 4-6 quart pot for one 1-1.5 pound lobster.
Do you put water in a lobster steamer?
Yes, fill the base just below the steaming tray or basket.
Should lobster pots have lids?
Yes, lids are vital for trapping steam and moisture.
Can you use a crab pot for lobster?
You can, provided it’s large enough for the lobsters to move around.
Can I cook lobster tails in a pot?
Yes. Use a 1-2 quart saucepan and keep covered by 1 inch of water.
Key Takeaways on Lobster Pots
-
Choose a large pot to prevent crowding and ensure even cooking
-
Target a 12+ quart stock pot or pasta pot for ease of handling
-
Stainless steel or aluminum offer durability and efficient heating
-
Match pot shape to cooking goals: narrow for speed or wide for broth
-
Look for straight sides, helper handles, lids, and pour spouts
-
Steamer and multi-cooker pots allow versatile cooking options
With the right pot, cooking lobster at home is easy and enjoyable. Focus on size, shape, and material to achieve tender, restaurant-worthy results. Getting the perfect pot helps take your lobster preparation to the next level.
How to Buy and Store Lobster
When choosing live lobsters from the market, look for the ones that are most lively, dont have any noticeable cracks on their shells, and do have all of their parts (not missing legs or claws). Look for lobsters that are 1 1/4 to 1 1/2 pounds, which is a good size for the average eater.
As soon as you get your lobsters home, put them in the refrigerator to keep them cold. Do not store them in tap water. Store them in a sturdy paper bag in your fridge.
If you have to transfer the lobsters, pick one up by its body, not claw or tail.
Lobsters can live only up to 36 hours after theyve been removed from seawater, so buy lobster the day you intend to cook it, and dont wait too long to cook it.
How to Humanely Kill Lobster
This age-old debate is ever-changing and ongoing as more research is done about lobsters and their ability to feel pain. Chefs and home cooks favor different methods, from stroking them on the head to using a knife to freezing.
Americas Test Kitchen performed some tests and, while we cant currently be 100% certain what approach is the most humane, they found that freezing lobsters for about 30 minutes before boiling sedates them, basically putting them to sleep. This caused the lobsters to move less upon hitting the boiling water.
We tested freezing lobsters for 20 to 30 minutes before boiling and can confirm that the lobsters were sedated and moved far less. As a bonus, its easier (and less risky) to remove the rubber bands while theyre sedated. Be quick getting them from the freezer to the pot for the best results.